NordicTrack Commercial 1750 vs Sole F85: Which Treadmill is Right For You?

Everyone has their own strengths, and it isn’t very nice to scrutinize individuals in a comparison-type battle. However, treadmills don’t have feelings like people do, so we’ll be doing just that with the NordicTrack Commercial 1750 vs Sole F85. 

I’ll be digging into the strengths and weaknesses of both of these powerful cardio machines. This is a good old-fashioned showdown, and I’ll be the judge. So sit back, relax, and enjoy the duel. 

So Many Treadmills, So Little Time

If you’re overwhelmed by the number of treadmills on the market, you’re not alone. There are hundreds of options available and each one could have good qualities for you, but how can you tell which one is the best pick? 

Luckily, the experts at Garage Gym Reviews (including moi) are here to save the day! We’re full of fitness knowledge––whether you’re curious about treadmill industry standards, warranty comparisons, or workout experience, we have you covered. After all, we’re a team of certified personal trainers, former college athletes, CrossFit coaches, and nutrition coaches. This is what we do, and luckily for you, we do it really well.

NordicTrack Commercial 1750 vs Sole F85: Video Review

Quick Look: NordicTrack Commercial 1750 vs Sole F85

NordicTrack sells a variety of cardio machines such as rowers, ellipticals, exercise bikes, and of course, treadmills. They’re underneath parent brand Icon Health & Fitness, which also owns popular brands like ProForm, iFIT, and Free Motion (amongst others). 

The Commercial 1750 is the less-expensive sibling to the Commercial 2450 treadmill, which clocks in at around $2,500. The 2450 features a larger touchscreen and a slightly more powerful motor than the 1750. The 1750 has a 14-inch touchscreen, powerful motor, and large deck for all of the activities.

Take a look at our full NordicTrack Commercial 1750 treadmill review.

On the other hand, the Sole F85 treadmill is the brand’s most expensive folding treadmill. Sole offers two other machines that are more expensive than the F85, but they’re non-folding treadmills.

Want to learn more? Check out our Sole F85 treadmill review.

Who Should Buy NordicTrack Commercial 1750

• Individuals who want decline options
• Those who love interactive programming 
• People who need great financing

NordicTrack Commercial 1750

NordicTrack Commercial 1750

GGR Score: 4.5

Check Price Save $200 for Black Friday

Product Highlights

• Spacious running deck
• Compatible with iFIT
• 14-inch touchscreen
• Incline and decline training
• Financing available

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Compatible with iFIT
• 3.5 CHP motor
• Free trial of iFIT subscription with purchase
• Treadmill with incline and decline training
• Foldable to save space (EasyLift Assist)
• Run that feels similar to road running
• Financing options available through NordicTrack
• Generous speed range
• Wide running deck
• Cooling fan

Cons

• Big footprint
• Heavy and not the easiest to move
• Price is around $2,000
• Warranty is voided if the treadmill is used/stored in a garage

Bottom Line

If you’re looking to add a workhorse of a treadmill to your home gym, we recommend the NordicTrack Commercial 1750.

Who Should Buy Sole F85

• Heavier folks
• People who want a long warranty
• Individuals who need more treadmill deck cushioning

Sole F85 Treadmill

Sole F85 Treadmill

Check Price

Product Highlights

• 4.0 HP motor
• Large running surface at 22” W x 60” L
• 400-pound user weight capacity
• Lifetime frame and motor deck warranty
• 15 levels of incline
• Well-cushioned
• Folding deck

Pros & Cons

Pros

• 375 lb weight capacity
• 4 transport wheels for portability (most treadmills only offer 2)
• Cushioned deck
• Incline range of 0% to 15%
• Powerful 4.0 HP motor
• Folding deck design, console fans, and tablet holder
• Integrated Bluetooth speakers
• 10 preset programs
• WiFi capabilities
• Compatible with Fitbit, Record, Mapmyrun and Apple Health
• Pre-loaded apps: Netflix, YouTube, ESPN, CBC News, NBC News, and CNN News

Cons

• Several reviewers report the cushioning is not as soft as comparable machines
• Difficult assembly
• Large footprint, even when folded

Bottom Line

With a 4.0 HP motor, the F85 is one of the most durable foldable treadmills on the market. With a large cushioned running surface, interactive display, WiFi capabilities and a fancy console with fans and speakers, the F85 is a fantastic choice for anyone looking to enhance their cardio workouts.

Comparison Chart: NordicTrack 1750 Treadmill and Sole F85 Specs

Key Similarities Between NordicTrack Commercial 1750 and Sole F85

• The same generously-sized running area of 22” W x 60” L
• Priced around $2,000
• Speeds maxes out at 12 MPH 
• Heavy machines with large footprints
• Foldable treadmills
• Water bottle holders (yay for hydration!)
• Touchscreens are built in

Important Differences Between NordicTrack Commercial 1750 and Sole F85

• The NordicTrack Commercial 1750 has a weaker motor than the Sole F85
• The NordicTrack Commercial 1750 has a larger touchscreen than the Sole F85
• The NordicTrack Commercial 1750 has a shorter warranty period than the Sole F85
• The NordicTrack Commercial 1750 has decline options and the Sole F85 only has incline
• The NordicTrack Commercial 1750 has a lower weight capacity than the Sole F85
• The NordicTrack Commercial 1750 has Google Maps and the Sole F85 doesn’t
• The NordicTrack Commercial 1750 is slightly heavier than the Sole F85

Workout Comparison: Sole F85 vs NordicTrack 1750

Although I’ve used the NordicTrack Commercial 1750 quite a bit, I haven’t had the pleasure of testing the Sole F85 for myself. However, I have used the Sole F63, which is essentially the less-expensive version of the F85. 

Both the F85 and the 1750 are extremely sturdy machines. If the F63 gives any indication to the F85’s durability, you likely won’t feel much movement even when cranking up the incline and speed. The 1750 is just as sturdy––I’ve tested it for jogging, walking, and sprinting and didn’t notice any play in the frame as I used it.

RELATED: Best Treadmill for Walking

Although both the 1750 and the F85 have touchscreens and interactive programming subscriptions to subscribe to, I prefer NordicTrack’s iFIT. iFIT has tons of different classes available on-demand for $39 per month (for multiple profiles). Whether you’re into running, strength training, or yoga, iFIT has a well-produced class for you. 

Sole has their own programming called STUDIO, which is $19.99 per month. This was only really refined in the past year, so the production quality, class variety, and instructors are less streamlined compared to iFIT. However, if you don’t want to pay $39 per month for iFIT, STUDIO may be a good option for you at around half the cost. 

Both the Sole F85 and the NordicTrack 1750 have the same speed range that taps out at 12 miles per hour. This is the industry standard––you’ll be able to complete an all-out sprint, a long-distance run, or a pleasant walk with either of these machines. 

In terms of incline, both the F85 and the 1750 have a maximum 15 percent incline, which is plenty for most people. However, the 1750 does have decline, and the F85 does not. If you’re interested in pretending to run down a hill (while in the comfort of your own air conditioning), you may appreciate the 3% decline you’ll find in 1750.

Although not apparent to the casual exerciser, the motor horsepower of both treadmills are strong. However, the F85 does feature a slightly stronger motor at 4.0 CHP (compared to the 3.5 CHP of the 1750). This just means the motor will be able to sustain serious running for longer lengths of time without struggling. 

RELATED: Best Incline Treadmill

Company Policies

Although it probably is not the first thing you look at when checking out fitness equipment, company policies are good to be aware of. Here’s a quick breakdown of the things you need to know about NordicTrack and Sole Fitness’ customer service and policies:

Warranty

The industry standard for a treadmill frame warranty is between 15 years to life (I always feel like a judge sentencing a suspect in a crime when I say that). 

Winner: Sole

NordicTrack

All of NordicTrack’s home treadmills have a 10-year frame warranty, which is below the industry standard of at least 15 years. I’ve always been surprised by this, especially since NordicTrack produces such sturdy machines. Maybe this is something they will amend in the future. 

Sole

Sole offers excellent warranties. All of their treadmills have a lifetime frame guarantee. Some of the higher-end models (like the Sole F85) have a lifetime motor and deck warranty as well. Sole Fitness definitely stands fully behind their products.

Returns

A typical return policy is usually 30 days from receipt. Most companies will charge return shipping and some will also add on a restocking fee.

Winner: Sole 

NordicTrack

NordicTrack has a return policy of 30 days from delivery. You will be responsible for a $250 shipping fee to get the machine back to the warehouse. 

Sole

Sole allows the customer to return a machine within 30 days of receipt. Plus, you don’t have to pay any return shipping fees, which is pretty unusual. 

Financing

Good financing is generally 0% APR for a number of months (depending on how expensive the machine is to start with).  

Winner: NordicTrack

NordicTrack

If you qualify, NordicTrack offers stellar financing through T.D Bank––you’ll get 0% APR for between 12 to 48 months.

Sole

Sole offers financing options through Citizens, which you have to qualify for. If you qualify, you could pay as little as $108 per month for the Sole F85.

NordicTrack Commercial 1750 vs Sole F85 FAQs

Caroline Lubinsky, CF-L1

Caroline is a former NCAA D1 Women’s College Soccer player who also played in the WPSL, the second highest level of professional women’s soccer in the United States. Although soccer was her first love, Caroline eats, sleeps, and breathes all things fitness. She credits her high school’s football coach, Jason Estep, with teaching her how to properly use a barbell at 15 years old and inspiring an enduring love for strength training. Caroline is also a CrossFit Level 1 Trainer. Content wise, Caroline has a background in Public Relations and previously worked in the Communication department at Appalachian State University. When Caroline isn’t writing or working out, she works with dachshund rescue groups and listens to way too many true crime podcasts.

Further reading

Force USA MyRack In-Depth Review

by Cooper Mitchell, GGR Founder

The Force USA MyRack is not only one of the most customizable racks available, but it's also one of the most feature-filled for those on a budget. After training in the MyRack over 30 days and testing (literally) every accessory they make, we can confidently recommend it to anyone looking for a budget squat rack. Read more

Treadmill Financing: Expert Tips to Chip Away at Your Home Gym Costs

by Ben Conroy

Need to ease into your new home gym purchase? This guide to treadmill financing will show you how. Read more

Eleiko IWF Weightlifting Training Bar Review (2024): A Premium Olympic Barbell From a Historic Brand

by Caine Wilkes, OLY, CNC, USAW-L1

A premium price tag that matches its premium quality. See if this Olympic lifting barbell fits your budget in this Eleiko IWF Weightlifting Training Bar review. Read more

Kensui EZ-VEST Weighted Vest Review: The Plate-Loadable Weight Vest

by Cooper Mitchell, GGR Founder

How does an Olympic plate loadable weighted vest compare to traditional weighted vests? Find out in our Kensui EZ-Vest Weighted Vest review. Read more