Mayhem Strength Bumper Plates Review (2024): These Colorful Plates Are A Joy To Look At, But How Do They Feel?

For those who train with a barbell, weight plates are an essential yet often overlooked aspect of building a home gym. Many gym owners spend plenty of time choosing the best squat rack or barbell, while the best weight plates can feel like an afterthought. 

There’s nothing wrong with this, but if you want to infuse some color into your home gym equipment and avoid the standard black or metal weight plates, Mayhem Strength’s neon fleck bumper plates are a fantastic choice. They’re durable, vibrant, and sure to turn heads—but are they worth the cost?

In this Mayhem Strength Bumper Plates review, I’ll share our final thoughts after months of extensive testing (and dropping) to help you decide if these plates deserve a spot in your home gym. 

We Know Bumper Plates

Here at Garage Gym Reviews, we test as many products as possible. Our testers, who include certified personal trainers, weightlifters, gym owners, and fitness enthusiasts, have tested dozens of bumper plates over the years, and we know exactly what to look for. 

For this review, our tester was Lindsay Scheele, CPT, CNC, the face of our Garage Gym Reviews Everything YouTube channel. Lindsay has used all kinds of bumper plates over the years, and she spent several months primarily using these Mayhem Strength Bumper Plates in her training before filming a full video review.

After spending so much time with these plates, Lindsay used our equipment testing methodology to calculate a final score, which rates each product in a number of specific categories, such as:

• Durability and construction
• Ergonomics
• Versatility
• Rubber density and bounce (for bumper plates)

Mayhem Strength Bumper Plates

Mayhem Strength Neon Fleck Bumper Plates

GGR Score: 4

Check Price

Product Highlights

• Ranges from 10 lbs to 55 lbs
• Neon colors in a fleck pattern
• Virgin rubber
• High durometer rating

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Unique color and pattern
• High durometer rating
• Low bounce
• Virgin rubber

Cons

• Not available in sets, only as pairs
• Pricier bumper plates

Bottom Line

With bright neon colors broken up in a speckled fleck pattern, Mayhem Strength Neon Fleck Bumper Plates are sure to make any home gym pop. Although a bit more expensive than black bumper plates, the neon fleck plates are made with a virgin rubber, which should minimize the rubber smell weight plates can have. Additionally, they have a high durometer rating—between 85 and 90—which will protect your floors with a dead, low bounce when dropped.

A Quick Look at the Mayhem Strength Bumper Plates

With a stunning design that immediately catches the eye, these are some of the most unique bumper plates we’ve seen. The plates say Mayhem Strength on them, but when you go to the Mayhem Strength website, only a few sizes are available. 

The full sets are available on GymBroFitness.com. We aren’t exactly sure how the two companies are related, but if you’re interested in picking up these plates, you’ll want to do your shopping on the GymBroFitness website. 

Slightly confusing branding aside, these vibrant plates come in a variety of weights and colors. If you’re looking for a way to add a splash of color to your gym, you’ll love them. They’re a bit pricier than we’d expect to see and cost more than popular brands like REP Fitness and Rogue, but we still like the plates quite a bit. 

If you’re a weightlifter or regularly use Olympic lifting in your training, commonly seen in workout styles like CrossFit, bumper plates are essential, as they’re meant to be dropped. They also work well with exercises like deadlifts, where the bar is repeatedly crashing into the floor.

RELATED: 13 Deadlift Benefits

Mayhem Bumper Plates are durable and built to withstand heavy use, and aside from a few minor design issues we’ll call out later, we think they’re a great choice for most people.

Before You Buy

• Mayhem Strength Bumper Plates are made of virgin rubber, which has no odor and is very durable.
• The plates use an interlocking design, but the ridged edge isn’t comfortable to hold. 
• They aren’t the cheapest plates, but the quality is high, and they should last for a long time.

Mayhem Strength Bumper Plates Video Review

Are the Mayhem Strength Bumper Plates Worth It?

These bumper plates are more expensive than we would have expected, but that doesn’t mean we don’t recommend them. If you’re on the fence, here’s who we think will love these plates the most.

Mayhem Strength Bumper Plates Specs

Experience Using the Mayhem Strength Bumper Plates

Lindsay Scheele, CPT, CNC, has used these plates weekly during her training sessions at the Garage Gym Reviews warehouse. She said that while she loves training with all of the equipment at our warehouse, she almost exclusively reaches for the Mayhem Strength Bumper Plates because the colors and design are so pretty. 

To quote Lindsay directly, “They just bring joy to me every time I look at them.”

At 3 inches thick, they’re a little bit thicker than something like an Eleiko competition plate, but they’re about the same size as many other bumper plates meant for home use. Because of the durometer rating of the rubber, Lindsay pointed out that they don’t have much bounce when dropping them. 

Unlike iron plates, bumper plates are specifically designed to be dropped on a barbell without damaging either the plates or the bar. This works well for Olympic weightlifting, an explosive type of lifting that can help improve power, strength, and speed¹.

RELATED: Bumper Plates vs Iron Plates

They certainly bounce a little, but compared to some other budget plates we’ve tested that seemingly bounce halfway to your chest, these plates feel pretty good. 

Lindsay also mentioned that the 2-inch collar fits very well on most barbells and machines. It’s easy to slide on and off but not so loose that it feels like it’s moving around constantly. 

Overall, these colorful plates are a great choice for home gym owners who want to add a unique look to their setup. 

RELATED: Crazy Ways to Use Weight Plates

Construction and Durability

For the construction and durability, arguably the most important part of a bumper plate, the Mayhem Strength plates earn a 5 out of 5. 

Lindsay has dropped these plates on the gym floor countless times during her training, as have others in the gym, and they still look great. The company website says these plates can be dropped 30,000 times before durability becomes an issue, which is a lot of drops. You may hit this number faster in a commercial gym, but home gym owners should get many years out of these plates.

The plates are made of 100% virgin rubber, which is meant to withstand regular wear and tear. After months of regular use, including plenty of dropping, the plates don’t show any scratches, dents, or other signs of damage. The virgin rubber also means the plates don’t have a strong odor when you first get them, which is great for home gym owners who’ll have these plates in a smaller gym. 

RELATED: DIY Weight Plates

According to the durometer rating of these plates, which measures the durability of rubber, the Mayhem Strength Bumper Plates are just as durable as bigger brands like REP Fitness and Rogue.

Ergonomics

The plates received a 3 out of 5 for ergonomics. Lindsay’s main callouts were with the ergonomics of these plates, and she wishes a few features were a little different. 

The plates have a bumpy edge that’s meant to provide enough grip and allow them to interlock. However, Lindsay feels this doesn’t work well when stacking the plates on a bar, especially if the bar doesn’t have collars.

She noticed that every time she dropped the bar, the plates bounced and separated without a tight collar. This is common with most bumper plates, of course, but it defeats the purpose of intentionally adding interlocking features. Lindsay noted that she’d rather have no edges at all so the plates can lay flat against each other on the barbell rather than an interlocking design that makes it difficult to get the plates evenly lined up. 

Lindsay had one other callout about the textured design, saying it felt a little “Ouchy,” a word she made a point of writing down. She asked several others in the warehouse for their opinion, and they all agreed that it felt like aggressive knurling, but in a bad way. Be prepared for a textured ridge that may be a little painful to grip. 

Mayhem Strength Bumper Plates vs Rogue Echo Bumper Plates

Rogue Echo Bumper Plates

Rogue Echo Bumper Plates

GGR Score: 3.5

Check Price

Product Highlights

• Great value for the quality
• Black-and-white contrast for easy weight identification
• 88/100 durometer rating
• 3-year warranty

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Tremendous value
• Shore A Durometer rating of 88
• Weight tolerance of these bumpers is +/- 1%
• Great for general training and CrossFit
• White lettering offers great contrast
• Stainless steel insert rings
• 25-45 lb plate variants are warrantied for 3 years

Cons

• Wide plates
• Maximum you can fit on the bar is less than 500 lbs
• May smell bad out of the box

Bottom Line

The Rogue Echo Bumper Plates are a great value plate based upon our review. Although they're cheaper than Rogue's flagship HG 2.0 Plates, they have extremely similar specs and warranty at a much lower price. If you need bumper plates for your garage gym, these are a great option. If you need them for your commercial facility or CrossFit Affiliate, we'd suggest going with something like Hi-Temps.

If you’re looking for a set of black bumper plates from one of the biggest names in fitness equipment, the Rogue Fitness Echo Plates are another option to consider. 

The Echo plates, available in both black and full-color sets, are similar to the Mayhem Strength plates in many ways. They’re sold in pairs or sets, available in 10- to 55-pound increments, and have a high durometer rating that results in minimal bounce. 

The main difference is the design and cost, which were our only two callouts with the Mayhem Strength Plates.

Unlike Mayhem Strength, Rogue uses flat plates that don’t have an interlocking design and don’t have the painfully bumpy edges. They’re also cheaper in most weights and sets. For example, a pair of 45-pound Mayhem Strength plates costs $275.99, while a pair of 45-pound Rogue Echo plates only costs $165. 

If you love the colorful designs and don’t mind spending more, we recommend Mayhem Strength Bumper Plates. However, if you prefer the flat design or want to save money, the Rogue Echo Plates are a better choice. 

For more, you can check out our in-depth Rogue Echo Bumper Plates Review.

Customer Experience 

The customer experience from GymBros Fitness, the company that sells Mayhem Bumper Plates, earns a 3 out of 5 rating. 

No free shipping is offered, and all returns are charged a 25% restocking fee. Several products are available on pre-order, but if you wish to cancel your order before it ships, you’ll be charged 20% of the fee as a penalty.

The company website has a phone number, email address, and contact form for reaching someone.

Ordering the Mayhem Strength Bumper Plates

At the time of writing, the Mayhem Strength Bumper Plates are currently out of stock, but the website says they’ll be restocked in December 2024. 

The plates can be purchased with a credit card, Amazon Pay, or financed through Sezzle at checkout, and shipping charges will vary depending on where you live.

Customer Reviews

At the time of writing, there is only one review on the company website, a 5-star review that praises the look and quality of the plates

Final Verdict of Our Mayhem Strength Bumper Plates Review

We really like the Mayhem Strength Bumper Plates, especially the bright color patterns. They’re certainly not cheap, and we wish they had smooth edges instead of the rough, somewhat painful grip areas, but everything else is great. 

Whether you’ve been lifting for decades or you’re preparing to start your fitness journey, these plates are a great choice that will fit any standard Olympic barbell. 

The rubber is very durable and doesn’t have a strong smell when unboxing, and there’s no excessive bouncing when dropping them. If you don’t mind spending a little extra money, Mayhem Strength Bumper Plates are a great way to add a splash of color to your home or garage gym. 

Full Rating

Mayhem Strength Bumper Plates

With bright neon colors broken up in a speckled fleck pattern, Mayhem Strength Neon Fleck Bumper Plates are sure to make any home gym pop. Although a bit more expensive than black bumper plates, the neon fleck plates are made with a virgin rubber, which should minimize the rubber smell weight plates can have. Additionally, they have a high durometer rating—between 85 and 90—which will protect your floors with a dead, low bounce when dropped.

Product Brand: Mayhem Strength

Product Currency: $

Product Price: 104.50

Product In-Stock: InStock

Editor's Rating:
4

Mayhem Strength Bumper Plates: FAQs

References

1. Morris, S. J., Oliver, J. L., Pedley, J. S., Haff, G. G., & Lloyd, R. S. (2022). Comparison of Weightlifting, Traditional Resistance Training and Plyometrics on Strength, Power and Speed: A Systematic Review with Meta-Analysis. Sports medicine (Auckland, N.Z.), 52(7), 1533–1554. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40279-021-01627-2

Matt Dustin, CES, PN1-NC

Matt is a writer and fitness coach who's been working in the fitness industry for 11 years. Before joining the GGR team, Matt was a freelance health and fitness writer for 11 years, writing for dozens of fitness websites, influencers, and wellness brands. He's also the author of three nutrition books published through Simon & Schuster. He currently lives in Las Vegas, NV.

Further reading

7 Best Exercise Mats (2024): Protect Feet, Knees, and Hips

by Lauren Strong, CPT

In this roundup, we picked five of the best exercise mats our product testers used for bodyweight movements, mobility drills, and core exercises. Read more

Gain Strength And Shape: Resistance Band Exercises For Glutes

by Lauren Strong, CPT

For those who train with a barbell, weight plates are an essential yet often overlooked aspect of building a home gym. Many gym owners spend plenty of time choosing the best squat rack or barbell, while the best weight plates can feel like an afterthought. There’s nothing wrong with this, but if you want to infuse some color into your home gym equipment and avoid the standard black or metal weight plates,  » Read more about: Mayhem Strength Bumper Plates Review (2024): These Colorful Plates Are A Joy To Look At, But How Do They Feel?  » Read more

Rogue US MIL Spec Crumb Bumper Plates Review: Improved Hi-Temps (2024)

by Cooper Mitchell, GGR Founder

In our Rogue US MIL Spec Bumper Plates review, you'll see why this is one of our absolute favorite plates for outdoor workouts and more. Read more

9 Moves to Add to Your Inner Chest Workouts for Strength and Hypertrophy

by Ravi Davda, CPT

A certified personal trainer breaks down what inner chest workout is best for increasing strength and muscle mass. Read more