How to Decide on the Best Personal Trainer Certification: NASM vs NSCA (2024)

You’re likely landing on this comparison because you’re wondering how to become a personal trainer. You’ve perhaps even narrowed down your choices to two stellar options within the fitness industry: NASM vs NSCA. 

If that’s the case, you’re well on your way to making a choice. I know it’s a hard one to make. I personally wrestled with the NASM (National Academy of Sports Medicine) vs. NSCA (National Strength and Conditioning Association) debate myself about six or so years ago. 

I went with NSCA-CPT. I won’t let that cloud my judgment, though. I talked with my Garage Gym Reviews teammates who have earned the NASM certification to hear their perspective, too.  

In this comparison, I’ll be walking you through the similarities and differences of NASM and NSCA certified personal trainer (CPT) programs. Both cover in-depth movement assessment, program design, exercise technique, and client behavior.  

That said, there are some differences in the learning modules and test-taking experience. Let’s dive in. 

NSCA-CPT

NSCA-CPT Certification

GGR Score: 4.1

Check Price

Product Highlights

• Certified personal trainer exam
• NCCA-accredited program
• 155-question exam
• Study materials sold separately

Pros & Cons

Pros

• NCCA-accredited program
• Provides accurate scope of practice
• In-depth approach to 1:1 coaching
• Multiple-choice question exam

Cons

• Study materials are separate from exam fees
• Exam fees are higher for non-NSCA members
• In-person exam only

Bottom Line

The certified personal trainer program from the National Strength and Conditioning Association (NSCA-CPT) offers an in-depth approach to coaching clients for safe and effective fitness programs. You’ll need to be CPR/AED certified to sit for the exam, be 18 years of age or older, and have a high school diploma. The NSCA-CPT exam is taken in-person at a proctored Pearson VUE testing center.

NASM-CPT Course

NASM Personal Training Certification Course

GGR Score: 4.6

Check Price

Product Highlights

• Various study packages offered
• New digital learning platform
• The foundation of the course is based on NASM’s Optimum Performance Training Model (OPT) which is a systematic approach to personal training for every type of clien
• Prerequisites  – CPR and high school diploma or GED
• Covers behavioral change to assist clients with personal hurdles
• Focus on client assessments to develop plans best suited for each person

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Lots of study materials available: textbook, app, videos, and podcasts
• Built-in opportunities for post-certification internships
• NASM is NCCA-certified
• Discounts often available
• Financing available
• Options for remote or in-person exam
• Other courses available for advanced learning
• Bundle CPT with nutrition and other courses for a discount

Cons

• Higher cost than some other certification programs
• Textbook not included in two most basic packages
• Textbook/online training modules alone may not prepare you well for exam
• Short time frame to take the exam, especially if you work full-time

Bottom Line

NASM’s digital CPT program is a highly reputable and in-depth certification program for anyone looking to become a personal trainer.

NASM vs NSCA Comparison Chart

Quick Look At Two Personal Training Certifications: NASM vs NSCA

The NASM and NSCA programs both grant you CPT certifications once you pass the exam with a 70% score or higher. However, the learning modules and materials it takes to prepare for each exam vary. 

Both organizations offer accredited certifications through the National Commission For Certifying Agencies (NCCA). This is important for fitness professionals who want to secure a job at a commercial gym or convey authority in the industry.

RELATED: NASM Certified Nutrition Coach Course Review 

NCCA-accredited programs are often considered the gold standard for fitness certifications. Other NCAA-accredited CPT programs include: 

• American Council on Exercise (ACE)
• International Sports Sciences Association (ISSA) 
• American College of Sports Medicine (ACSM) 
• National Council on Strength and Fitness (NCSF) 

RELATED: ACE vs NASM 

NASM vs NSCA Costs

There are four tiers to the NASM program. You can buy the most basic package for $899 which is a totally online course that includes a digital learning platform, high-end learning videos, audio chapter summaries, exercise demonstration library, biodigital 3D models

handouts and resources library, practice exam, and access to a test prep mobile app. 

With each tier there are added benefits and the top two options also include a hardcopy textbook. All NASM CPT below options come with two exam options, which I’ll dive into a bit later.  

• Self-Study: $899
• Premium Self-Study: $1,399
• All-Inclusive: $1,899
• Elite Trainer Bundle: $3,499

With the NSCA you’ll have a la carte purchasing options for everything from the exam to the study materials and practice test. I personally found this method helpful—at the time I was working as an apprentice at a gym, making very little money. I rented the textbook on Amazon for around $50 for a six month period, purchased the study guide, downloaded the detailed content outline (DCO), and got to work reading and studying. 

I opted out of the online study course and leaned heavily on the mentors I met through my apprenticeship. While that may have worked for me, consider the fact I was getting hands-on experience during my studies. That course of action won’t work for everyone. 

It’s also worth noting that if you decide that you’ll benefit from the online study course, the only way you can purchase it is if you buy the bundle, which includes the textbook and online prep course.

Here’s a cost breakdown of what’s available directly on the NSCA store: 

• NSCA membership (optional): $130 annually 
• NSCA-CPT exam: $300 ($435 for non-members)
• Study guide: $20 for members ($27 for non-members)
• Quizzes and practice test: $150 for members ($200 for non-members)
• Exercise Technique Manual for Resistance Training, 4th Edition: $80 for members ($89 for non-members)
• Essentials of Personal Training, 3rd Edition: $119 for members, $109 for non-members)
• Bundle: Online Study Course and Essentials of Personal Training book: $269 for members ($265 for non-members

I also opted not to buy the practice exam, which I do not recommend. It’s well worth the investment. The wording on test questions can be tricky, especially when asked about contraindications. 

NASM vs NSCA: Prerequisites

Both NASM and NSCA require you to have a high school degree and be 18 years of age or older. NASM also notes you can have your GED and the NSCA notes high school degree or equivalent. 

Both organizations also require a CPR and AED certification. NASM requires the CPR/AED cert before the exam and the NSCA allows it to be taken up to one year after the certification exam. 

NASM vs NSCA: Exams

Test-takers for the NASM exam have two options, but either way you’ll need a 70% or higher to pass. According to an updated report from NASM, the pass rate is 79% for the proctored exam and 90% for the non-proctored exam. Here are the two test options:

1. NASM Personal Trainer Certificate: This is a non-proctored, open-book exam. It has 100 exam questions. You’ll be given three attempts to pass your exam. 
2. NASM Certified Personal Trainer: This option is a closed-book, NCCA-accredited certification exam. It’s proctored (in-person or online), takes 2 hours, with 120 multiple choice questions. 

Kate Meier, NASM-CPT, USW-L1, and GGR head of content writes in her NASM review, that you won’t have to study too far beyond the basics in nutrition. The example she uses is being able to determine which types of vitamins are fat-soluble. 

RELATED: Best Turmeric Supplement 

She also notes it’s important to know your exercise assessments. Be sure you understand movement flaws and what that could mean for your client in terms of overactive and underactive muscles. 

Kate also notes that getting familiar with a few key terms and root words was helpful for reading and answering test questions. She says terms like broncho, osteo, and -ectasis came up quite a few times. 

The NSCA-CPT exam also requires a 70% grade to pass the exam. It has 155 multiple choice questions and you can take up to 3 hours. According to the NSCA, the pass rate in 2022 was 66% for first-time candidates attempting the CPT exam. 

The NSCA updates and revises exams nearly every two years, but at the time I wrote this comparison this is how the categories are broken down: 

• 32 client assessment and evaluation 
• 45 program planning
• 43 exercise technique
• 20 safety, emergencies, and legal procedures
• 15 non-scored questions

You can use the detailed content outline (DCO) to help you prepare and study for the above categories, which is exactly what I did. 

It’s worth noting that I experienced several questions with a bit of math—which can be intimidating if you’re more skilled with the arts and languages, like me. 

For example, there were questions on how to calculate a client’s one rep max (or three rep max) based on some of the information provided about a client training with submaximal weights (or vice versa).

There were also questions related to target heart rate and blood pressure, which are simple formulas and doable to recall, but you will need to memorize them because it’s likely they’ll show up in the fitness evaluation category. 

I also remember several questions where I needed to recall calories per macronutrient to figure out how many calories a client was intaking per day. 

RELATED: What Should My Macros Be?

Although that may seem like outside the scope of practice for a CPT, on the DCO one line item states that you’ll need to effectively communicate and educate using information from peer reviewed resources regarding general nutrition, supplements, nutrient timing, hydration, and daily caloric needs.

NASM vs NSCA: Recertification

NASM and NSCA both have a two-year recertification cycle. That means you’ll be required to stay up-to-date with the fitness industry with continuing education in order to keep your credentials. 

For NASM, it will be required to earn 2.0 NASM-approved CEU credits every two-year period. And for NSCA, you’ll need 6.0 CEU credits every reporting cycle. 

Each organization scores CEUs a bit differently, but you can expect that things like attending seminars (in-person or online), passing quizzes, watching education videos, publishing articles, and completing coursework can earn you CEUs. If you’re not utilizing credits directly through the NASM or NSCA, both organizations require materials to be approved to be considered for CEUs. 

Additional Programs and Offerings

Both organizations offer more than just CPT certifications. Here is a look at what else you can prepare for and get certified in (or use toward your CEUs):

Additionally, NASM offers tons of specialization courses including virtual coaching, senior fitness, youth fitness, and group fitness instructor to name a few. 

NASM vs NSCA: Final Thoughts

When it comes to the NASM vs NSCA debate, there is no doubt it’s a difficult decision. Both offer NCCA-accredited programs and exams that can get your foot in the door training clients at commercial gyms. 

Both the NASM and NSCA certifications and study materials will prepare you to assess new clients, evaluate imbalances, and create programs for performance training, resistance training, or cardiovascular exercise. 

While training athletes is possible if you have your CPT, both certification organizations offer advanced degrees that are specific to athletes and team sports and dive deeper into biomechanics and physiology. 

The biggest difference is the coursework and study methods. The NSCA has mostly self-study options while NASM offers multiple tiers of self-study and guided methods. 

Here are some things to keep in mind: 

• Pricing for the NASM certification is in four tiers running from $899 to over $3,000. This includes coursework and the exam costs. Each package includes additional features. 
• NASM offers two methods to take your final exam: A proctored NCCA-accredited option and an open-book, non-accredited exam. 
• The NSCA only offers in-person proctored exams in a Pearson VUE testing center. 
• The exam cost for the NSCA-CPT is separate from any coursework or study materials. You will have to buy each item separately. 

NASM vs NSCA: FAQs

Lauren Strong, CPT

Lauren is an NSCA-Certified Personal Trainer working with clients of all ages and skill levels. She specializes in coaching the squat, bench, and deadlift and enjoys introducing beginners to barbell training. Before becoming certified, she worked in marketing roles after graduating from the University of Maine with a BA in Journalism. Writing for Garage Gym Reviews blends her two passions: writing and lifting. Lauren spends her leisure time in the kitchen, reading fiction, and taking nature walks. She's also an avid downhill skier, learning how to ski when she was just two years old. She lives in Maine with her husband and two cats.

Further reading

Creatine vs Whey: Should You Take Both?

by Destini Moody, RD, CSSD, LD

Creatine vs whey sounds like the ultimate supplement battle, but there’s no reason for these two to duke it out for supremacy. Read more

Prime RO-T8 Handles Family In-Depth Review

by Cooper Mitchell, GGR Founder

The Prime Fitness RO-T8 Handles and other attachments are some of the most engineered cable attachments ever created. After using the entire RO-T8 family over the course of 45 days, we can confidently give a high recommendation for anyone doing cable work. Not only are they incredibly versatile, but they are also comfortable and easy to use. Read more

DIY Slam Ball For Under $25

by Cooper Mitchell, GGR Founder

A Slam Ball is an incredibly versatile piece of equipment for any garage gym. However, it's also often pretty expensive. Thankfully, we found a way to make a DIY Slam Ball that can weigh all the way up to 100 pounds. Read more

SWAT Officers Epic Powerlifting Garage Gym

by Cooper Mitchell, GGR Founder

Sergeant Cort is a strong guy with a big heart. Not only is his garage gym the envy of his neighborhood, but when he's not putting up crazy numbers on the platform, he's a member of SWAT busting in doors and serving his community on the local Police Force. Cort is no doubt, Garage Gym Built. Read more