Hydrow vs Peloton (2024): Two Top Rowers Compete for Your Home Gym

Here at Garage Gym Reviews, we’re big fans of rowing machines. We like machines that allow you to work on your cardiovascular endurance all while stimulating a full-body workout for your muscles, too.

No matter your fitness level or reason for wanting a rower, you’re probably landing on this comparison because you want the best rowing machine you can find. In this comparison of Hydrow vs Peloton, we’re going to explore the similarities and differences between these two high-end brands. 

Hydrow Rower

Hydrow Connected Rower

GGR Score: 4.2

Check Price

Product Highlights

• Sleek and sexy design
• 16″ touchscreen display
• Magnetic resistance done right
• Gorgeous virtual rowing workouts filmed on location all over the world
• Smooth rowing experience

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Consistent and smooth magnetic rower
• Engaging interactive programming
• Ability to compete against others via a leaderboard
• Sleek and modern design

Cons

• Just under $2,500 for the Hydrow Essentials Package
• Additional subscription fee for programming
• Limited customer service contact options

Bottom Line

This is a fantastic, advanced rowing machine ideal for people who have the money to spend and the desire for trainer-led workouts.

Peloton Row

Peloton Row

GGR Score: 4.0

Check Price

Product Highlights

• Available for pre-order
• Products begin shipping in early December 
• Anodized and powder-coated frame
• 23.8” swiveling touchscreen
• Peloton All-Access membership required

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Form Assist: Live feedback on form and technique
• Set your own personal pace target for each class
• Shipping and setup included (excluding wall anchor)
• Folds away for vertical storage
• 30-day triall: If you’re not satisfied schedule a pickup from Peloton and you’ll be refunded

Cons

• More expensive than competitors
• Requires additional monthly membership
• No financing options available
• No customer reviews
• 12-month warranty is short for such an expensive product

Bottom Line

The Peloton Row is an expensive premium rower with the high-quality Peloton programming users love.

Hydrow vs Peloton Comparison Chart

Quick Look: Hydrow vs Peloton

You will see in this comparison that the Peloton and Hydrow offer a lot of similar (and desirable) features. Although we haven’t personally tested the Peloton rower, we published a first look Peloton rower review right after the brand announced it was taking preorders in September 2022. That said, we think our expert product tester’s experience with plenty of other rowers, plus the Peloton app, exercise bikes, and treadmill, gives us insight to lay out the pros and cons for this comparison.

Hydrow offers two different rowing machines: the Hydrow Connected Rower and the Hydrow Wave. The Hydrow Wave is the smaller, more compact, and less expensive model.

For the purpose of this comparison, we’re going to keep our attention on the Connected Rower because it is the most similar to the Peloton Row. That said, if you’re interested in the less expensive version of the Hydrow, be sure to check out our Hydrow Wave review, which includes a video of GGR founder Coop Mitchell comparing the two Hydrow machines side-by-side. 

Key Similarities Between Peloton Row and Hydrow

• Low-impact, full-body workouts
• Monthly memberships required for full functionality  
• Different types of workouts (not just rowing workouts) including yoga, pilates, and strength training
• Live and on-demand workouts
• Upright storage solutions  
• If you decide to cancel your membership on either machine, you can use manual mode or Just Row feature
• Touchscreen swivels side-to-side for on (or off) rower workouts 
• Peloton All-Access membership and the Hydrow Membership cost $44 per month

Important Differences Between Peloton Row and Hydrow

• Peloton Row is $700 more than the Hydrow
• Hydrow classes are filmed on water, not a studio
• Hydrow has a higher user weight capacity by 75 pounds
• The monitor can fold down on the Peloton Row for compact upright storage

Technology Comparison

One of the main differences between the technology you’ll see on the Peloton vs the Hydrow rowing machine is the way classes are filmed and presented to you. Hydrow classes are all filmed outdoors on the water, while Peloton offers a mix of indoor studio sessions and scenic outdoor classes. 

It’s also worth mentioning that Peloton rowing classes are only available if you buy the Peloton Row. As of this writing, rowing content is not available to folks who just have the Peloton app. I mention that because you can hack other cardio equipment by using a non-Peloton brand and streaming the programming through the Peloton app—but in the case of the rower, you cannot use that trick. 

Both machines have a $44 monthly subscription fee to access interactive programming, on-demand classes, and live workouts. It’s also worth mentioning the full membership access allows you to see and rank in the leaderboard-style competition that both subscriptions offer.

That said, I wanted to look into what happens if you decide to cancel or pause your membership. After a little digging I verified on both websites that you will still be able to use a manual mode, aptly named Just Row on both machines. 

In addition to a library of workouts, both the Peloton and Hydrow feature large swiveling touchscreens so you can easily view the instructors for rowing workouts and other studio workouts like yoga, pilates, and dumbbell strength sessions (which are offered on both). 

The Hydrow also allows you to sync with other apps like Strava and Apple Health for heart rate monitoring and tracking activity. The Peloton Row also has Apple Health connectivity for Apple Watch users. 

Both rowers also feature Bluetooth speakers and can connect with wireless headphones so you can hear the music and the instructors’ voices and background music without disturbing anyone in your household (especially during early morning workouts). 

RELATED: Best Rowing Apps

Workout Feel

When it comes to rowing machines, you have a few different options for resistance type including air, water, and magnetic resistance. Although similar, each resistance style delivers a different experience. 

It’s worth noting that both the Hydrow and Peloton both offer whisper-quiet workouts with a belt drive system, but the odd thing is that there is not a lot of information about Peloton’s resistance mechanism. 

The Hydrow website explicitly states the rower uses computer-controlled electromagnetic resistance, while the Peloton Row spec chart reads: electronic resistance. If you’re confused about what that means, you’re not alone. It sounds ambiguous to our experts here at GGR, too. However, from our product testing experience and research the Peloton also features magnetic resistance. 

That said, I will mention that Hydrow features a patented electromagnetic resistance mechanism with the goal of creating a more realistic water rowing sensation. 

Construction Differences

One of the standout features on the Hydrow is the sleek, modern design. In Coop’s YouTube video of the Hydrow review, he even notes it’s even sleek enough to leave it in your living room without the need for stowing it away. 

I personally think it’s a pro that it looks good because in order to achieve vertical storage (like you might do with a Concept 2), you’ll need to make an additional $80 purchase of an upright storage kit so it can be tethered to the wall. 

I will mention that the Hydrow Connected Rower is a hefty machine, weighing 145 pounds, which might not make it easy to prop up into the vertical position. The challenge of storing aside, the weight of this machine makes it sturdy, which eliminates excessive movement or shaking. Overall, this machine is built to last with an aluminum and steel frame. 

The Peloton Rower comes in at 156.5 pounds made from an anodized powder-coated aluminum frame, molded plastic sheathing to cover the hub, and woven fabric pull strap. The heavy frame will give you a locked-to-the-ground feel and provide a solid base for rowing workouts.

When you’ve completed a Peloton class, you’ll have the option to stow your rower vertically like the Hydrow. However, the main difference is the fact that the purchase of a Peloton rower includes the Upright Wall Anchor. To store vertically, you’ll need to use the folding mechanism on the upright that holds the touchscreen display and fold it down toward the monorail before tipping upright. 

Additionally, the ergonomic seat and handlebar on the Peloton Row will provide comfort during short HIIT rowing workouts and long endurance sessions alike.  

Company Policies

When you’re making an investment of a few thousand dollars, it’s good to know what your options are when it comes to financing your purchase, warranty policies, and the steps to take if you need to make a return. 

Warranty

The Hydrow limited warranty period includes five years on the structural frame and upright storage kit. However, this five-year period excludes any moving parts attached to the structural frame like moving arms and position adjustment. It’s also worth mentioning the fine print states that the warranty policy does not apply to damage or equipment failure from normal wear and tear, incorrect assembly, or improper maintenance. 

You will have a 12-month warranty on the Hydrow screen, electronics, and other components including handles, straps, seat, and hinges. Labor also has a 12-month warranty period. 

Peloton also offers a 5-year warranty on the frame, which protects against defects in workmanship. There is also a 12-month warranty on all other components of the rowing machine, HD touchscreen, and labor. 

Return Policy

When you’re a new customer, you can buy a Hydrow and receive a 30-day risk-free home trial. To receive this risk-free offer, you will need to make your purchase on hydrow.com (not at a third-party retailer like Best Buy). 

If during this 30-day period you feel like the Hydrow is not the right piece of fitness equipment for you, just contact Hydrow member services within 30 days of delivery so the company can arrange a free pickup of your Hydrow rower. 

That said, if you are not a new customer and you don’t qualify for the risk-free trial you’ll be on the hook for a $250 return shipping fee. You also will not receive a refund for the original shipping, delivery, or installation charges. 

Peloton has a policy similar to Hydrow—if you are a first-time customer (meaning you’ve never bought or returned a Peloton Bike, Tread, or Rower) you can qualify for the home trial program. 

If you’re going to make a return, you’ll need to contact the Peloton Support Team within the 30-day window to coordinate your return, which will include a pickup in most areas. To arrange  your return, you can use the live chat function on the Peloton website or call the support team at 1-866-679-9129. 

However, if you are not a first-time customer, returning the Peloton rower will cost you $250 in return shipping fees and you will not receive a refund for original shipping or delivery fees. 

Financing Options

Hydrow offers financing through Klarna with payments as low as $52 per month with 0% APR for 48 months. Receiving 0% APR is subject to a credit check. That said, standard purchases will have 19.99% APR. 

Peloton offers financing through Affirm. If you qualify, you can receive 0% APR for a 12-month loan. Affirm has longer terms as well—ranging from 24 to 43 months—with a 4.99% interest rate, which is also dependent on your credit history. 

It’s worth noting that with either brand, when you finance your purchase it does not include your monthly membership to access interactive programming.

Final Thoughts: Hydrow vs Peloton

Although similar in many ways, the Hydrow and Peloton rowers have distinct differences. Here are the ones I think are important to call out: 

• You will not find studio classes on the Hydrow membership, only outdoor classes filmed with athletes on water. 
• The Hydrow rower has a user weight capacity of 375 pounds, which is higher than the 300-pound limit of the Peloton Row. 
• The Peloton Row comes with a wall anchor for upright storage, while the Hydrow sells the anchor kit separately for $80. 
• The Peloton is priced about $700 more than the Hydrow Connected Rower. 
• You might be able to snag a deal if you use a Hydrow discount code or shop during one of the major holiday sales. 

Hydrow vs Peloton FAQs

Lauren Strong, CPT

Lauren is an NSCA-Certified Personal Trainer working with clients of all ages and skill levels. She specializes in coaching the squat, bench, and deadlift and enjoys introducing beginners to barbell training. Before becoming certified, she worked in marketing roles after graduating from the University of Maine with a BA in Journalism. Writing for Garage Gym Reviews blends her two passions: writing and lifting. Lauren spends her leisure time in the kitchen, reading fiction, and taking nature walks. She's also an avid downhill skier, learning how to ski when she was just two years old. She lives in Maine with her husband and two cats.

Further reading

Smith Machine Workouts: Get a Full Body Workout Using a Single Machine

by Christopher Covello

Looking to add some variation to your weightlifting regimen? Check out our CPT-selected Smith machine workouts for a fresh way to get in your strength training! Read more

NordicTrack Commercial R35 Review (2024): A Recumbent Bike with Interactive Programming

by Caroline Lubinsky, CF-L1

Check out our NordicTrack Commercial R35 review to see if this recumbent bike is right for you. Read more

Echelon EX-8s Review (2024): It’s Good, But Certainly Not the Best Exercise Bike

by Anthony O'Reilly CPT, CNC

Here at Garage Gym Reviews, we’re big fans of rowing machines. We like machines that allow you to work on your cardiovascular endurance all while stimulating a full-body workout for your muscles, too.No matter your fitness level or reason for wanting a rower, you’re probably landing on this comparison because you want the best rowing machine you can find. In this comparison of Hydrow vs Peloton, we’re going to explore the similarities and differences between these two high-end brands.   » Read more about: Hydrow vs Peloton (2024): Two Top Rowers Compete for Your Home Gym  » Read more

Does Creatine Help Build Muscle? Yes, But The Answer is Complex

by Lauren Strong, CPT

Here at Garage Gym Reviews, we’re big fans of rowing machines. We like machines that allow you to work on your cardiovascular endurance all while stimulating a full-body workout for your muscles, too.No matter your fitness level or reason for wanting a rower, you’re probably landing on this comparison because you want the best rowing machine you can find. In this comparison of Hydrow vs Peloton, we’re going to explore the similarities and differences between these two high-end brands.   » Read more about: Hydrow vs Peloton (2024): Two Top Rowers Compete for Your Home Gym  » Read more