Best Water Rowing Machine: WaterRower Vs. Ergatta And More

Like other types of cardio equipment, rowing machines come in several different styles and run the gamut of price ranges. Water rowing machines are unique in that they truly mimic the feel of rowing a boat on the water, unlike magnetic rowing machines or air rowing machines. If you’re interested in that real-water feel, keep reading for our guide to the best water rowing machines.

Row, Row, Rowing Our Way To Fitness Since 2012

Our team of certified personal trainers, CrossFit coaches, and fitness equipment experts assembled this list of the best water rowers based on our collective decades of experience with rowing machines of all types. 

Best Water Rowing Machines in 2024 

• Best Rowing Machine Overall: WaterRower Natural Rowing Machine
• Best Interactive Water Rowing Machine: Ergatta 
• Best Smart Water Rowing Machine: CITYROW Max
• Best Water Rower Under $1,000: Mr. Captain Water Rower
• Best Budget Water Rowing Machine: Sunny Health and Fitness Obsidian Surge 500

Best Rowing Machine Overall: WaterRower Natural Rowing Machine

Good for: People who want a classic water rowing machine with a natural wood look and simple monitor 

Best Rowing Machine Overall

WaterRower

GGR Score: 3.8

Check Price

Product Highlights

• Water resistance simulates outdoor experience
• Handcrafted wood for beautiful aesthetic
• One of the quietest water rowing machines

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Water resistance simulates outdoor experience
• The body is made of handcrafted wood
• One of the quietest water rowing machines
• Very aesthetically pleasing
• 700 lb weight capacity
• Optional expert assembly

Cons

• Prices start around $1,100
• Wood can dent and chip
• Weighs 117 lbs
• Monitor location isn’t convenient

Bottom Line

The WaterRower Natural is an excellent rower that uses (drumroll) water instead of air as its main mode of resistance. This closely simulates the resistance you would receive in real-life rowing, and it sounds pretty amazing, too.

The WaterRower Natural Rowing Machine tops our guide to the best rowing machines as the best water rowing machine. After testing and researching more than a dozen water rowing machines, our expert product testers maintain that the WaterRower brings the best value for the money. 

For a tad over $1,100, you get a handcrafted rowing machine with a sturdy solid-wood frame with many à la carte tech additions and programming options. 

Although the WaterRower doesn’t have any built-in programming, there are many third-party options for dynamic programming. The WaterRower’s S4 monitor is not innately Bluetooth-enabled—just ANT+ compatible for heart rate monitor connectivity—but the WaterRower ComModule (priced separately) turns your S4 monitor into a Bluetooth device. 

If you take that route, you can then use essentially any of the best rowing apps, including WaterRower Connect, which turns your phone or tablet into a secondary performance monitor. 

There is also SmartRow hardware, which makes the WaterRower experience even more immersive. SmartRow hardware allows you to connect to the SmartRow app, which precisely calculates wattage output and provides more in-depth metric tracking. 

According to our testing team, the “out-of-the-box” programming really just tracks the basics on the S4 monitor but you can manually preset some workouts, including time, distance, or stroke rate goals. 

I personally love that customers can choose how tech-enabled they want their WaterRower to be. Believe it or not, not everyone wants a high-tech smart rowing machine with a fancy-schmancy HD display! 

Customers love how well-made this machine is, with many reviews commenting on how quiet and smooth it is to ride as well as how nice it looks (buyers don’t mind leaving it in living spaces because it looks nice). 

Best Interactive Water Rowing Machine: Ergatta 

Good for: Trainees who want a smart water rowing machine with a large touchscreen display and gamified workouts

Best Interactive Water Rowing Machine

Ergatta Rower

GGR Score: 3.9

Check Price

Product Highlights

• Water resistance rower
• Aesthetically pleasing
• Crafted from cherry wood
• Gamified programming
• Can be stored vertically

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Smooth rowing experience
• Lots of useful data
• Aesthetic style
• Gamified programming

Cons

• Water has to be replaced every so often
• Resistance cannot be changed

Bottom Line

This machine is aesthetically-pleasing (which is an often overlooked attribute for equipment that lives in peoples homes) and the programming is interesting and engaging. If you’re looking for a water-powered rowing machine and want programming that’s different from what’s typically offered, you'll be a fan of the Ergatta.

The Ergatta rower gives you everything the WaterRower provides, plus an insanely fun gamified workout platform that streams on a beautiful 17.3-inch touchscreen display—but you’re gonna pay for it with a price tag starting at nearly $2,200. 

Ergatta is essentially a retrofitted version of the WaterRower with more tech capabilities and built-in programming, thanks to the screen, which can stream workouts. 

Although the Ergatta platform doesn’t have trainer-led workout programs like you see from most competitors (i.e., Hydrow, Echelon), it does support various gamification methods as well as open and scenic row workouts to keep you on track to reaching your goals. 

According to Coop, who has extensively tested the Ergatta rower and other smart rowers, “The way the platform is using programming to keep you on pace and to push you is very smart, and overall, I like the minimalist style of the programming. I like how simple Ergatta is. There isn’t a ton to fiddle with and the data it provides is great.”

Like WaterRower, the build quality on Ergatta is strong, sturdy, and natural. Wood in general won’t prove as durable as steel over time, but Ergatta has a very substantial build, Coop says.

One of the best parts about Ergatta? It’ll arrive at your doorstep fully assembled—all you have to do is add water.

Read our full Ergatta Rower review.

Best Smart Water Rowing Machine: CITYROW Max Rower

Good for: Trainees who want a platform with instructor-led workouts

Best Smart Water Rowing Machine

CITYROW GO Max Rower

GGR Score: 3.9

Check Price

Product Highlights

• High-quality machine
• Some of the best interactive programming
• Pre-Assembled
• Easy to move around

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Smooth rowing experience
• Quality interactive programming
• Rower comes pre-assembled
• Fairly portable; screen is able to be folded down

Cons

• Water used has to be replaced every so often
• Resistance isn’t adjustable
• Expensive at almost $2,200

Bottom Line

Overall, I really enjoyed using the CITYROW GO Max Rower. Would I generally recommend it over the Hydrow? No, because the Hydrow’s interactive rowing classes are second to none. However, if you’re someone who is interested in doing a variety of workouts through streaming in tandem with a high-quality machine, then I would recommend the CITYROW GO Max Rower to you.

The CITYROW Max is a unique indoor rowing machine simply because it’s one of few water rowers that features native trainer-led workouts, including live classes and on-demand workouts. 

The frame and footplates of the CITYROW Max are wooden, but the slide rail looks much like what you’d find on the Concept2 RowErg (also known as the Concept2 Model D rower). It’s also got an all-black design, as opposed to the cherry wood, ash wood, and other natural looks on water rowers. 

This rowing machine arrives almost fully assembled; all you’ll have to do is hook up the touchscreen and fill the water tank to get the full rowing experience. 

RELATED: WaterRower vs Concept2

Hardware aside, the CITYROW Max is a tech behemoth: It features a large sweat-resistant screen that can connect to bluetooth headphones and heart rate monitors. You can use the chest strap style or sync your rower to your Apple Watch or other fitness tracker. The studio programming is well done with high-quality cameras and nice lighting. The touchscreen is snappy and there are physical volume rocker buttons on the side, along with the power button that’s easy to access. 

You do have to pay for a monthly subscription to access CITYROW GO, the app that works with this rowing machine. For $29 per month or $348 per year, you get access to a constantly updated library of low-impact, full-body workouts, so I’d say it’s worth it. 

Your subscription includes much more than just rowing workouts, and instead encompasses many types of  workouts you can do in your home gym: strength training, interval training, yoga, and more. 

Read our full CITYROW Max review.

Best Water Rower Under $1,000: Mr. Captain Water Rowing Machine

Good for: People who want a classic rowing machine like the WaterRower, but with a Bluetooth monitor and for less than $1,000

Best Water Rowing Machine Under $1,000

Mr. Captain Rowing Machine

Check Price

Product Highlights

• Oak veneer frame
• Budget-friendly
• Cover and water pump included
• Bluetooth monitor

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Aesthetic wooden oak veneer 
• Affordable
• Expert assembly available
• Rower cover and water pump included

Cons

• No built-in workout streaming platform 
• Small console
• Lower weight capacity (320 lbs)
• Not made of solid hardwood

Bottom Line

The Mr. Captain water rowing machine is an affordable piece of cardio equipment with many good reviews online.

The Mr. Captain Rowing Machine looks a lot like the WaterRower and Ergatta, but it costs a fraction of the price. So what gives? Well, after some internet investigation (we haven’t had the chance to try this machine yet), we learned that the Mr. Captain rower is not, in fact, constructed of solid wood—even though it says this in the Amazon product description. 

According to several customer reviews, another in-depth Mr. Captain water rower review, and analysis of the assembly manual and product specifications, it became clear that this rowing machine is actually made of MDF engineered wood (medium-density fiberboard). The most telling factor that caused me to do further research was the low weight of this product. At 58.5 pounds dry, I immediately thought there was no physical way the rower was constructed of solid wood as the average consumer views “solid wood.” 

By modern furniture standards, engineered wood is often considered “solid wood,” but it is not constructed of solid oak, cherry wood, ash wood, or other hardwoods you’d find on WaterRower or Ergatta. 

I want to be clear that this does not mean the Mr. Captain rower is poor quality or a bad product. In fact, quite the opposite: Most buyers are happy with the build quality of the Mr. Captain rower, except for those who feel scammed by thinking they were buying a solid oak rower and receiving an MDF one. 

If you know what you’re buying—and you’re A-OK with it—I believe you’ll love the Mr. Captain rowing machine for its Bluetooth-enabled LCD monitor that tracks time, strokes per minute, total strokes, calories burned, distance, and pulse (if you have a compatible heart rate monitor.) It also features three preset workout programs: manual mode, target mode, and interval mode. 

All in all, this mid-range rowing machine is a good option for people who want a nice-looking water rower with basic metric tracking, but aren’t worried much about overuse of the machine or detailed, scary-accurate stat tracking. 

Best Budget Water Rowing Machine: Sunny Health and Fitness Obsidian Surge 500

Good for: Beginners looking for an entry-level rowing machine for a good price 

Best Budget Water Rowing Machine

Sunny Health & Fitness Obsidian Surge 500 Water Rowing Machine

Check Price

Product Highlights

• Water based resistance with a flywheel and 16 hydro blades intended to mimic true rowing
• Durable frame with a slide rail length of 42 inches and a maximum user weight of 300 pounds
• Features a sweat resistant handlebar and high-profile molded padded seat designed for comfort and functionality
• Rubber transport wheels make it simple to move the rower when not in use and it can be stored upright to save space

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Smooth slide
• Budget friendly
• Quiet
• Works well for tall individuals
• Solid frame supports up to 300 pounds
• Compatible with ANT+ heart rate monitors
• Adjustable floor stabilizers

Cons

• Swivel designed footplates interfere with form and stability
• Water reportedly leaks for some users

Bottom Line

The Sunny Health & Fitness Obsidian Surge 500 Water Rowing Machine is a value purchase offering a water-based rowing experience on a solid frame.

Sunny Health & Fitness makes some of our favorite budget-friendly rowers with magnetic resistance. After testing dozens of pieces of gym equipment from this brand, it simply felt right to include the Sunny Health and Fitness Obsidian Surge 500 water rowing machine as our best budget water rower. 

Although our product testers haven’t gotten their grips on the handlebars of this rower yet, we’re confident in our experience with other Sunny Health and Fitness products and our expertise in rowing machines. (We’ve got this product on order, and if anything changes, we’ll update this guide right away.) 

Anyway, the Obsidian Surge 500 would suit all fitness levels fine, but it’s an especially great option for beginners who aren’t sure if they’ll stick to rowing for exercise, thanks to its palatable $500 price point. 

This budget-friendly water rowing machine features a hydro-fan with 16 blades, a lightweight but sturdy steel frame, pivoting pedals, and front-mounted wheels for transport and easy storage. It also has a large, contoured, padded seat and an LCD monitor that tracks total time, meters, strokes per minute, calories, and more (although some customer reviews say the monitor isn’t as accurate as on higher-end rowers). 

The 300-pound weight capacity is impressive given its low price and smaller-than-average construction—the Obsidian Surge 500 has a short slide rail of 42 inches, far shorter than the 54 inches found on Concept2 rowers, which are considered the gold standard in rowing machines. 

Read our full guide to the best budget rowing machines.

Other Water Rowing Machines We Researched

We haven’t tested the below rowing machines yet, but based on their popularity on Amazon and other reviews sites, we think they’re worth pointing out and briefly covering until we can get our hands on them. 

XTERRA ERG600W Water Rower

This water rowing machine is similar to the Sunny Health and Fitness Obsidian Surge 500, our top pick for budget water rowers, in that it has a steel frame and small LCD monitor that tracks basic rowing metrics.

Snode Wooden Water Rowing Machine

I’m excited to try this rowing machine because it’s the only foldable wooden water rowing machine that I’ve ever come across. It looks much like Ergatta, Mr. Captain, and WaterRower, although it is made of MDF with a beech wood veneer, not a solid natural wood. 

Sunny Health & Fitness Hydro+ Dual Resistance Magnetic Water Rowing Machine

This unique water rowing machine uses both water and magnetic adjustable resistance. It’s one of the only water rowers with different levels of resistance—traditional water rowers have user-dependent resistance just like air resistance rowers.

Stamina Elite Wave Water Rowing Machine

I wasn’t impressed after my initial experience with Stamina rowing machines, specifically the 35-1405 ATS Air Rower. However, based on the product description (and the price tag of about $1,200), the Stamina Elite Wave Water Rowing Machine seems to have much sturdier construction and features many more tech capabilities. 

Marcy Pro Water Resistance Rowing Machine

The Marcy Pro water rower (NS-6070RW) looks like a solid mid-range rowing machine with good specs for a rower under $1,000. It has many positive reviews on Amazon and, at the time of writing, an average rating of 4.6 out of 5 stars.

How We Chose The Best Water Rowing Machines

Our roster of product testers includes several industry-certified experts, including personal trainers, CrossFit coaches, functional training specialists, corrective exercise specialists, and equipment know-it-alls. 

As total gear junkies and fitness enthusiasts, we invest our efforts in in-depth brand and market research and hands-on testing to bring you the best guides, including this list of the best water rowing machines. 

Here are the criteria we judge rowing machines on: 

• Footprint (dimensions and space required) 
• Storage options (Does it fold? Can it store upright?) 
• Adjustability (foot cradle, seat, display, and handle adjustments)
• Ergonomics 
• Delivery and setup (Is expert assembly available?) 
• Construction (materials used, design, engineering)
• Durability 
• Tech capabilities (Bluetooth? App-compatible? Heart rate monitoring?) 
• Programming (Built-in programming? Is it interactive?) 
• Customer reviews (What are people saying about this?) 
• Customer service
• Warranty, financing, and returns 
• Value 

When testing rowing machines, our team completes a variety of workouts, including long endurance workouts, HIIT rowing workouts, and everything in between. We make sure to take full advantage of the features available on the machine to paint the best picture. 

Benefits Of Water Rowing Machines

Water rowing machines provide all the benefits of rowing machines in general—improved cardiovascular health, namely—but there are also a few benefits of water rowing machines that you won’t get on other types of rowers, including: 

• A very visually appealing piece of equipment. Many people buy water rowers specifically so they can keep the equipment in a living space without it being an eyesore. 
• A realistic on-the-water feeling. As much as air rowers and magnetic rowers claim to mimic the feeling of rowing in a real paddle boat, they don’t…At least not as much as water rowers do. 
• Unlimited resistance. Water rowing machines don’t have defined resistance levels like magnetic rowing machines do. When using a water rower, the faster and harder you row, the more the resistance increases due to the flywheel interacting with water in the tank.

How To Use A Water Rowing Machine

Water rowing machines operate just like other types of rowing machines. No matter what type of rower you are using, your rowing stroke should include four steps: 

• Catch
• Drive
• Finish
• Recovery 

You can find an in-depth explanation of rowing technique, plus a video demo and free workout, in our guide: How to Use a Rowing Machine.

What To Look For In A Water Rowing Machine

In your hunt for the best water rowing machine for you, consider these factors. 

Price 

A top-of-the-line water rower will cost $1,000 or more, with the most technologically advanced models costing upward of $2,000. Mid-range water rowers will run you about $700 to $900, while budget-friendly options hover around the $400 to $600 price range.

Construction And Durability

If longevity is a key deciding factor for you, look for solid natural wood water rowers or water rowers with steel frames. Make sure to read product descriptions carefully and differentiate solid natural wood from solid wood, which can often mean MDF. Water rowing machines made of engineered wood aren’t bad, but they most likely will not last as long as their real wood or steel counterparts. 

Console And Programming

Some water rowing machines have large, interactive touchscreen displays while others sport a basic LCD monitor. In general, those with HD displays have built-in programming or function in unison with a subscription to a workout app; those with LCD monitors typically have little to no built-in programming, but may be Bluetooth-compatible with a number of apps. Either way, you’ll want a console that at least tracks your total time and total meters rowed.

Space And Dimensions

By nature, most water rowing machines are big, bulky, and heavy. Less expensive models tend to take up less space (smaller machine = lower cost of production). If space is a concern, consider a budget-friendly model or look for models that store upright or fold. 

Adjustability And Ergonomics 

A rower is no good if it doesn’t fit your body. For example, people who are tall or who have long legs should pay extra attention to the slide rail length of a rowing machine, as this will determine whether or not they are able to reach full leg extension—54 inches is considered the gold standard of slide rail length Look also at the type and number of adjustments on the foot cradles, console adjustability, handle angle, seat contour, and the height at which the slide rail sits above the ground. 

Ease of Use And Maintenance

Water rowing machines require more maintenance than magnetic and air rowing machines. Specifically, you’ll need to keep the water clean and fresh so the tank doesn’t grow mold or bacteria. Ideally, you won’t have to change the water more than every four to six months. Some brands offer water cleaning tablets to extend maintenance intervals.

Water Rowing Machine FAQs

Commonly asked questions about rowing machines are: 

Amanda Capritto, CPT, CES, CNC, CF-L1, CSNC

Amanda is a content writer and journalist with extensive experience in the health, fitness, lifestyle, and nutrition niches. Before joining Garage Gym Reviews, she worked as an independent writer for various brands and outlets.Her work has appeared in national and global digital publications, including Health.com and Shape.com (Meredith Corporation), CNET (Red Ventures, formerly ViacomCBS), LIVESTRONG (Leaf Group), Verywell Fit and The Balance (DotDash), SlickDeals (Goldman Sachs/Hearst), Health Journal, and more.Now, Amanda brings her expertise in fitness to the GGR team by testing equipment and writing authentic, honest reviews on everything you might need to stock your home gym.

Further reading

Titan Leg Press Hack Squat Review 2024: Globo Gym Machine with Home Gym Value

by Caine Wilkes, OLY, USAW-L1

This leg machine combines two of the most popular machines in commercial gyms. Check out our thoughts on it in our Titan Leg Press Hack Squat review. Read more

Best Cheap Pre-Workout (2024): Aim to Get Big On a Budget with These Pre-Workouts

by Destini Moody, RD, CSSD, LD

You don’t need to break the bank to amp your workout up a notch. Check out our list of the 8 best cheap pre-workout supplements, approved by a dietitian. Read more

12 Tips for Running in the Rain

by Kaylia Sammut

Want to squeeze in a workout but the weather isn’t agreeing? Here are our tips for running in the rain. Read more

Quest Protein Powder Review (2024): Should You Pick Up This Supplement From A Well-Known Brand?

by Megan Toomey, MS, RD, CSR, LDN

In our Quest protein powder review, find out if this popular supplement is all it’s cracked up to be. Read more