Peloton Bike Plus Review (2024): Is It Better Than the Original Peloton Bike?

If the film industry has taught us anything, it’s that making a sequel can be a risky move. You either get something like The Godfather Part II, which is arguably better than the original (yeah, I said it), or you get Grease 2, which was so bad I bet most of you didn’t even know it existed. 

Our Peloton Bike+ review looks at whether this revamped version of the world’s most famous indoor cycling bike is one of the good sequels, or if it’s a major flop. We’ll also give you our thought on whether those who already own the original Peloton Bike should bother upgrading to the Bike+. 

The Amount of Exercise Bike Reviews We’ve Done Is Off the Chain 

Listen, I’m just going to give it to you straight: We know our stuff when it comes to exercise bikes. We’ve sat on and pedaled on dozens of them to learn the best ones for your home gym, whether you’re just looking for a stationary bike, a bike you can use at your desk, or an air bike to prep for your next CrossFit competition. 

We’ve also used many of these bikes in our roles as certified personal trainers, CrossFit coaches, and competitive athletes. You can count on us to recommend fitness equipment that will work for you no matter your training goal, budget, or space constraints. 

Peloton Sequel

Peloton Bike+

Check Price

Product Highlights

• Top-notch immersive training
• Live classes and leaderboards
• Requires monthly subscription
• 23.8-inch HD rotating touchscreen
• Constructed from welded steel
• Powder coat finish

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Rotating screen to easily transition between workout modalities
• Compact footprint
• 360-degree sound
• Quiet
• Top-of-the-line technology features
• Comfortable
• Free delivery

Cons

• Disappointing warranty
• Subscription is required to use bike
• Expensive

Bottom Line

The Peloton Bike+ is a piece of cardio equipment that brings training from home to a new level. With exclusive access to countless workouts and virtual scenery, this bike could be a worthy investment for anyone who has the means.The Peloton Bike+ also makes it easy to stay on track with your fitness goals as users can easily pair their Apple Watch to share metrics. In fact, users can just tap their Apple Watch to the Bike+ screen to instantly track cycling workouts. If you’re someone who loves to analyze workout stats, these features make it seamless.

A Quick Look at the Peloton Bike Plus 

The Peloton Bike+ was released in September 2020, in the thick of Peloton’s peak of popularity, as an upgraded version of the original bike. The bike itself, from the handlebars down to pedals, is largely the same as the first one, but with a few additional features. 

The Bike+ has a 23.8-inch screen that rotates 360 degrees (the OG model has a 21.5-inch screen that tilts), a better audio system, and an auto-follow function that automatically adjusts the resistance to your Peloton trainer’s instructions. The bike plus also has a digital resistance calibration that allows for a smoother ride.  

Just like the first Peloton, an all-access membership to the Peloton app is the best way to get the ultimate Peloton experience. The live classes and on-demand home workouts are still some of the best we’ve seen on any piece of smart home gym equipment. 

Our Tips

• Not sure this is the right stationary bike for you? Peloton offers a seven-day home trial period so you can try it out for yourself.

Is the Peloton Bike Plus Worth It?

We wondered the same thing, so we reached out to our friend Alie Atkins, who was a big fan of the original Peloton and recently upgraded to the Bike+. Her answer was a definitive “yes.” 

And though the Garage Gym Reviews team hasn’t tried it out for ourselves just yet, we can see why she’d say that. We’ve used the OG Peloton Bike as well as several Peloton alternatives that have many of the same features, so we can see how coupling them with the great Peloton classes would make this a go-to pick for anyone looking for a great exercise bike. 

RELATED: How to Choose an Exercise Bike

At just under $2,000, it’s also one of the best values for those looking to replicate the boutique studio cycling class experience at home. 

But that doesn’t mean we’d recommend it for everyone. Here’s a few people we think might enjoy it as much as Alie, and those who might want to look at other exercise bikes. 

Peloton Bike+ Specs

Taking the Peloton Bike+ For a Ride 

The Peloton Bike+ shares many of the same specs as the original Peloton Bike: A 38-pound flywheel, 100 levels of micro-adjustable magnetic resistance, and easy adjustment of the seat and handlebars. So we, along with Alie, expected the same Peloton experience from the Bike+ as the first one. 

But Alie says pedaling on the Bike+ feels “smoother” than it does on the original, which is something we noticed in other online reviews. Both bikes have the same flywheel and belt drive system, so in theory there shouldn’t be any difference between the two. 

RELATED: Peloton Bike Review

This smoother ride is due to the fact that the second Peloton has an auto-calibrated resistance system, which essentially adapts to your resistance changes overtime. 

With the first Peloton, there’s no such function and you may need to calibrate the bike’s resistance system if you’re experiencing any issues with it (which involves removing the water bottle holder with a screwdriver and placing a wedge tool in between the flywheel’s magnets).

Automatic Resistance Adjustment 

The automatic resistance adjustment is something we’ve used on the Echelon Smart Connect EX-3 bike, and we liked it there. On the Peloton Bike+, this feature kicks on during on-demand classes when a trainer instructs you to either increase or decrease the resistance. But instead of having to turn the resistance knob, your bike adjusts the difficulty for you (this feature can be turned off if you prefer to change the resistance manually). 

Alie says she has a love-hate relationship with the auto-follow feature. 

“I struggle a little bit more in terms of trying to keep up and not feeling like I’m either going to quit because it’s too hard, or that my legs aren’t turning to jello with it automatically adjusting,” she says. “It definitely makes for a harder cycle and pushes me to do what I should have been doing.”

Her fiancé, on the other hand, is a big fan. “He thought it was annoying having to manually change the resistance on the old bike and felt like it caused some delay or focus away from his workout each time the instructor has you change resistance speeds,” she says. 

Rotating Screen

The Peloton Bike+’s rotating screen not only makes following off-bike workouts like bootcamp much easier, but it also comes in handy during cycling classes that end with stretches. 

“I like being able to get off the bike, move away from it, and still be able to finish the cool down stretch without feeling like I had to be right up against the bike to follow along,” Alie says. 

Sound System

The Bike+ has front-facing speakers with rear-facing woofers (which help with bass) to create a surround sound system for the rider. Alie and other reviewers said they were blown away by the sound quality, and that it helped get them through their workouts. 

“I’m a music person when I workout, so this was huge for me in terms of keeping me in a motivated state,” she says. 

Alie’s not alone, and there’s a lot of research backing up the idea that a great playlist can help you complete a grueling cardio session.  

Other Tech Features

The Peloton Bike+ can connect to your Apple Watch (via the Apple GymKit integration) or other fitness tracker to track your heart rate and other metrics. 

There’s also a USB port that allows you to charge your phone, a camera and microphone for video chats with friends during live classes, Bluetooth connectivity, and a headphone jack. 

Pedals

Peloton utilizes Delta-compatible aluminum pedals, which requires cycling shoes or cleats. You can swap out the pedals for ones that can be used with athletic shoes. 

Conveniences 

The Peloton Bike+ has two water bottle holders and dual dumbbell racks. You don’t get a media shelf or fan, but you can easily find some on Amazon that are compatible with the Peloton.  

Classes

Don’t get us wrong, Peloton makes a great bike, but what they’re really known for is their live and on-demand classes. Thousands of people have canceled their gym memberships because they find they’re able to get just as good of a workout, if not better, at home through the classes. 

RELATED: Best Online Workout Programs

Alie says she struggled to find classes or exercises that she actually looked forward to every day, but that the Peloton changed that. It’s not hard to see why, as Peloton has some of the best instructors in the industry. Many of them have gone on to become celebrities themselves and launch their own online training programs, bringing thousands of their adoring fans along with them. 

For $44 a month, you get an all-access membership to the Peloton app and its thousands of classes and workouts for everything from cycling (obviously) to bootcamp, strength and conditioning, yoga, pilates, and more. 

You can access Peloton classes via the app and without a Peloton bike for $12.99 per month. 

Durability and Construction 

The Peloton Bike+ is a well-made piece of equipment, featuring a welded steel frame that has a 297-pound weight capacity. There are more budget-friendly exercise bikes with higher weight capacities (the MYX II Bike can hold 350 pounds), but we haven’t seen many complaints about Peloton wobbling when used by taller or heavier riders. 

There are some complaints that Peloton’s hardware isn’t the best, and one of the most common issues was the pedals falling off. This is annoying in and of itself, but customers have also complained that it’s difficult to schedule a repair for any such issues.   

Portability

The Peloton Bike+ weighs 140 pounds, but the transport wheels make it a breeze for anyone who needs to move around their home gym or apartment. At 59 inches in length and 23 inches in width, we don’t anticipate many people having difficulty fitting it into their workout space. 

Peloton Bike+ vs Peloton Bike

The Original

Peloton Indoor Exercise Bike

GGR Score: 4.3

Check Price Save $150 for Black Friday

Product Highlights

• 21.5″ touchscreen for immersive training
• Live classes and on-demand cycling sessions
• Leaderboard-style competition
• Adjustable screen, seat, and handlebars
• 5-megapixel front-facing camera
• Bluetooth connectivity

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Immersive experience
• Access to thousands of classes, challenges, and a large variety of workout options
• Compact footprint
• Sleek design
• Financing options
• “Try before you buy” option

Cons

• Disappointing warranty
• Membership is required to use bike
• Expensive
• Shipping is not included

Bottom Line

One of the more expensive options for virtual biking, the Peloton Bike is designed to be an all-in-one fitness solution on a high-quality cardio machine. You’re paying not only for the bike, but the unique training experience it makes accessible from the comfort of your home.

The question most people are probably asking: “Is the Peloton Bike+ any better than the original Peloton?” We asked Alie, who has used both Pelotons, and she responded that she would go back in time and just get the Bike+ in the first place. 

“After having the first bike and then upgrading we were like, ‘OK, we should’ve just gotten the Bike+,” she says. 

Her reasoning for saying this included the better sound system, smoother flywheel, and the auto-follow function. Alie got hers when Peloton was offering a rebate for trading the first Peloton in for the new bike, but if you have neither and are wondering if it’s worth the extra $800, we’d say we agree with her for the most part.  

Despite the large price difference between the two Pelotons, you’re still only getting a five-year frame warranty for the Peloton Bike+, and only 12 months for all other parts. In our opinion, we think a more expensive bike should come with a better warranty, especially since the industry standard is around 10 years for the frame. 

There’s also been multiple complaints of poor customer service when people need to take advantage of the warranty.

We’re happy to hear that the Peloton Bike+ seems to have a smoother ride than its predecessor, but we’re not big fans of the seat or pedals that either bike uses. 

The rotating screen is a big upgrade from the original’s swiveling screen, especially if you’re looking to take advantage of the wide array of classes offered through the Peloton app, which in our opinion is one of the best personal training apps for Android or iPhone users.

If you’re a cyclist who’s just looking for the best value exercise bike, we think the OG Peloton is the better option. But if you’re someone looking for a piece of equipment with the best features, especially when it comes to getting an immersive workout experience, the Peloton Bike+ is the way to go. 

Check out our full Peloton Bike vs Peloton Bike Plus comparison piece for a full showdown between these two bikes. 

Peloton Bike Plus vs Echelon EX-8s 

A More Expensive Alternative

Echelon EX-8s

Check Price

Product Highlights

• 24-inch curved HD touchscreen
• Monitor pivots 180-degrees
• Dual-ring rear flywheel design
• 15 LED lights to indicate workout metrics
• Dual speakers
• 32 magnetic e-drive levels
• Bluetooth resistance controls
• Dual water bottle holders

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Immersive experience
• 32 levels of resistance
• Dual-sided, SPD-compatible pedals
• Large, interactive HD touchscreen
• Multiple position handlebars
• Bluetooth 5.0 connectivity
• 1.8 GHz processing speed is fast

Cons

• Required paid membership required for use
• Disappointing warranty
• Uncomfortable seat

Bottom Line

If you’re looking for a fully immersive riding experience on a high-quality bike, the Echelon EX-8s is a solid choice. It is costly and does require a membership, so keep that in mind when making your purchase.

The Echelon EX-8s is the top-of-the-line model in Echelon’s Connect Bike Series, which was launched to compete with Peloton. The EX-8s is the most like the Peloton Bike+ in terms of functionality and the features it comes with, but at a price tag of around $2,300.

There are 32 magnetic resistance levels that can be controlled via Bluetooth, dual front-facing speakers, a curved HD touchscreen that replicates road cycling and can be rotated 180 degrees for off-bike workouts, and a flexing frame to reduce impact to your joints. 

The Echelon Fit App costs $34.99 per month for an all-access membership, and like Peloton also includes strength, yoga, and other non-bike workouts. The instructors aren’t as motivating as Peloton’s, and the production quality is a bit lower as well, but it still offers great programming for people of all fitness levels and interests. 

Despite being a more expensive bike, Echelon only gives you a year of coverage on the bike, which is worse than Peloton’s five-year warranty. That, along with the fact that the Peloton Bike+ is $300 cheaper, is why we’d recommend Peloton over Echelon. 

Want a look at Echelon’s other bikes? We pitted Echelon vs Peloton in a showdown that features all of the company’s bikes. 

Peloton Bike+ vs NordicTrack S22i Studio Bike 

A Great Alternative

NordicTrack S22i Studio Bike

GGR Score: 4.5

Check Price Save 15% for Black Friday

Product Highlights

• 24 digital resistance levels
• Incline and decline adjustments
• Fully rotating touchscreen

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Large 22" smart HD touchscreen
• Incline and decline ability
• Compatible with iFIT
• Adjustable seat
• Adjustable handles
• Dual-sided pedals
• Fan
• Comes with 2 3-lb dumbbells
• 24 digital resistance levels

Cons

• Expensive
• iFIT membership not necessary, but most beneficial
• Difficult to assemble
• Can’t be stored in the garage (brand states doing so will void the bike’s warranty)
• Hard to move and weighs more than 200 pounds

Bottom Line

This is the bike to get if you want an indoor cycling bike with interactive programming, incline and decline capabilities, and all the extras.

NordicTrack vs Peloton: A battle of cardio giants. But who’s the victor here? 

Both the Peloton Bike+ and the NordicTrack S22i Studio Bike have a rotating touchscreen (Peloton’s is 23.8 inches and NordicTrack’s is 22), automatic resistance adjustment, front-facing speakers, and magnetic resistance (NordicTrack only has 24 resistance levels, compared to Peloton’s 100). 

One big thing NordicTrack has that Peloton doesn’t have is incline and decline options, which is particularly great if you’re a cyclist looking to replicate outdoor riding or just want to challenge yourself. 

You also get hybrid pedals, so you can wear cycling shoes if you like with the added convenience of being able to ride with athletic shoes. 

If space is a big deal for you, Peloton is the way to go. The S22i Studio Bike weighs more than 200 pounds, and we found the screen got in the way when you went to move the bike. If space isn’t a concern, we personally recommend NordicTrack because it comes with incline/decline, a 10-year warranty on the frame, and it’s about $100 cheaper. 

Check out our full NordicTrack S22i review for a full look at one of our favorite exercise bikes. 

Peloton Bike+ vs Bowflex VeloCore 

Lean With It

Bowflex VeloCore

GGR Score: 4.2

Check Price $700 off plus free shipping for Black Friday

Product Highlights

• Simulates outdoor bike riding
• Easy to use
• Large monitor
• Interactive programming
• Incredibly stable and durable

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Leaning feature activates core muscles
• Large monitor with lots of information
• Durable with almost no shaking while in use
• User-friendly and simple to get started

Cons

• Difficult assembly with unclear instruction
• Limited music options with JRNY membership
• Uncomfortable seat
• Sub-par warranty

Bottom Line

We were very impressed with the Bowflex VeloCore. It’s a durable, innovative exercise bike that will appeal to a lot of people. We would consider adding it to your fitness equipment repertoire.

The Bowflex VeloCore’s main appeal is its “leaning feature,” which helps to activate more core muscles and makes you feel like you’re trying to hook a turn on an actual bike. 

These two bikes are for two different people: The Peloton Bike+ is for the person who wants engaging programming and an easy-to-use stationary bike to stay fit at home, whereas the VeloCore is for those who want to feel like they’re on a bicycle even when they’re indoors. 

Check out our full Bowflex VeloCore review for more information on this bike. 

Warranty, Financing, Returns

Peloton’s warranty is disappointing, to say the least, with only five years for the frame and a year for all other parts. That’s not the worst policy we’ve seen on an exercise bike, but considering the price you’re paying for it we would’ve liked to see something closer to the industry standard of 10 years. 

There are financing options that allow you to pay as little as $47 per month, with 0% APR if you qualify. 

Still not sure if the Peloton Bike+ is for you? You can try it out for 30 days and return it if you end up not liking it. 

Ordering and Assembling the Peloton Bike+

All Peloton bikes are assembled by a customer representative, which is included in the $250 fee that’s tacked onto your order price. This can lead to a delay in delivery times, depending on how many people Peloton has available for a certain area. 

Customer Reviews

With more than 2,100 reviews as of this writing, the Peloton Bike+ has a 4.7 average rating. Many claim the bike helped them commit to reaching their fitness goals during the pandemic, and that it was well worth upgrading from the original Peloton bike.  

The main complaints center around the poor durability of the bike’s hardware, specifically the pedals. 

Final Verdict of Our Peloton Bike+ Review

Are you looking for top-notch programming and like cardio machines that come with cool tech features? We think you’ll love the Peloton Bike+, and to be honest, the price tag isn’t the worst when compared to other high-end exercise bikes. 

We think serious road cyclists will want to look elsewhere for a more durable bike, as well as one that can recreate the feeling of pedaling on an open road. But if you’re simply looking for a quick cardio workout in your home, the Peloton Bike+ can deliver. 

Peloton Bike+ Rating

Peloton Bike+

Our Peloton Bike+ review looks at whether this bike is truly better than the original Peloton exercise bike.

Product Brand: Peloton

Product Currency: USD

Product Price: 1995.00

Product In-Stock: InStock

Editor's Rating:
4.4

Peloton Bike Plus Review FAQs

Anthony O'Reilly, CPT, CNC

Anthony O'Reilly is a NASM-certified nutrition coach and personal trainer whose work has been featured in Muscle & Fitness and BarBend, and previously was an award-winning reporter and photographer for newspapers on Long Island and Queens, NY. After spending most of his life overweight, he dropped 80 pounds and took control of his health and fitness. Outside of work, he still enjoys Little Debbie cakes but offsets them with rigorous hikes and workouts. He's an avid Manchester United supporter, through thick and thin.

Further reading

Earth Fed Muscle Review (2024): Is This Clean Protein Powder a Winner?

by Destini Moody, RD, CSSD, LD

In this Earth Fed Muscle Review, we talk about our experience using this grass-fed whey supplement with one of the shortest ingredient lists out there. Read more

Torroband Review (2024): Are These Solid Tube Bands Worth The Price?

by Lauren Strong, CPT

Find out about our experience with these tube bands in this Torroband review. Read more

How Many Sets per Muscle Group per Week: Advice From A Certified Personal Trainer

by Ravi Davda, CPT

If you’re wondering how many sets per muscle group per week you need to do, look no further. A personal trainer gives sample workouts based on different goals. Read more

NordicTrack A.C.T. Elliptical Review (2024)

by Roger Lockridge

In our NordicTrack A.C.T. Elliptical review, we break down the specs of this machine and offer alternatives. Read more