Peloton Tread vs NordicTrack: An Old West Showdown

Pitting the Peloton Tread vs NordicTrack treadmills feels like the never-ending battle between Microsoft and Apple. Both brands have a cult-like following, with people swearing by their features and user experience, promising to never use anything different. 

Peloton and NordicTrack have similar fervent fans, although Peloton hasn’t been on the fitness scene nearly as long as NordicTrack. If we’re talking history, NordicTrack has been producing treadmills (and other equipment) since the 1970’s. On the other hand, Peloton first released the Tread in 2018, following in NordicTrack’s well-established footsteps a cool 40 years later. 

Although experience in an industry is great, it isn’t everything. Forward-thinking brands like Peloton push innovation forward, and force companies like NordicTrack to produce better products for the consumer. Let’s see how the ever-popular Peloton Tread stacks up against NordicTrack’s fleet of treadmills. 

Not Your Run of the (Tread)Mill Comparison

At Garage Gym Reviews, our expert product testers and reviewers carefully analyze every facet of the fitness equipment we write about. Besides comparing the specs to industry standards, it’s important to us to have had our hands (and feet) on the machines we’re talking about whenever possible. This is the best way to deliver in-depth information you can trust. 

Plus, it’s safe to say we know a thing (or a thousand things) about fitness. After all, we’re certified personal trainers, former college athletes, and nutrition coaches. Talking about the fitness industry is as natural as breathing to us. 

Peloton Tread

Peloton Tread+

GGR Score: 3.74

Check Price Save up to $550 on Tread+ packages

Product Highlights

• Soft, cushioned treadmill
• Tilting touchscreen
• Can be powered via electric motor or manually
• Incline up to 15%
• 67-inch running deck

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Cushioned slat belt
• 67-inch running space is well above the industry standard
• 32-inch tilting touchscreen
• Can be used as a manual treadmill in "Free Mode"
• Adjustable incline up to 15%

Cons

• Expensive
• Weighs 455 pounds

Bottom Line

The Peloton Tread+ is a luxury cardio machine that features a cushioned slat belt, tilting touchscreen, and the high-quality interactive that made Peloton a household name. The downside: A very steep price tag.

NordicTrack Commercial 1750

NordicTrack Commercial 1750

GGR Score: 4.5

Check Price

Product Highlights

• Spacious running deck
• Compatible with iFIT
• 14-inch touchscreen
• Incline and decline training
• Financing available

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Compatible with iFIT
• 3.5 CHP motor
• Free trial of iFIT subscription with purchase
• Treadmill with incline and decline training
• Foldable to save space (EasyLift Assist)
• Run that feels similar to road running
• Financing options available through NordicTrack
• Generous speed range
• Wide running deck
• Cooling fan

Cons

• Big footprint
• Heavy and not the easiest to move
• Price is around $2,000
• Warranty is voided if the treadmill is used/stored in a garage

Bottom Line

If you’re looking to add a workhorse of a treadmill to your home gym, we recommend the NordicTrack Commercial 1750.

Comparison Chart

Here’s a quick breakdown of the prices and treadmill models available from both Peloton and NordicTrack:

Quick Look: Peloton Tread vs NordicTrack Treadmills

Peloton currently only produces the Tread, as the Tread+ has had some safety issues the brand needs to work out. If you’re interested in purchasing the Tread+ in the future, you can sign up for notifications on the Peloton website. You can purchase the regular Tread starting at $3,495 or take advantage of one of the bundles for between $3,740 and $3,820. The packages above base level include extras like dumbbells, water bottles, mats, heart rate monitors, yoga blocks, and yoga straps. 

NordicTrack currently produces eight different treadmills, although the brand does like to annually phase out models in favor of new options. As of fall 2023, the lineup is as follows: 1750, 2450, Elite, X22i, X32i, EXP 14i, EXP 10i, and EXP 7i. The two machines on closeout are the Elite 1000 and the C 1100i. The prices of these treadmills vary widely––you can get the EXP 7i for as little as $1,099 or the Elite with a 32-inch touchscreen for around $4,500.

Who Should Buy a Peloton Tread?

• Someone who wants live classes
• People who love a good playlist
• Individuals who like a less-cushioned deck
• Folks who like bootcamp-style workouts

Take a look at our Peloton Tread review.

Who Should Buy a NordicTrack Treadmill?

• People who want a lengthier warranty on their treadmill
• Individuals who want a longer treadmill deck
• Those who want a powerful motor
• Folks who want a large incline range

Check out our take on the best NordicTrack treadmills.

Key Similarities Between NordicTrack Treadmills and Peloton Treads

• Both have stellar interactive programming––iFIT and the Peloton app.
• Both brands offer excellent financing options.
• Both brands have responsive touchscreens on their treadmills.

Important Differences Between NordicTrack Treadmills and Peloton Treads

• NordicTrack has longer warranties on their treadmills than Peloton.
• NordicTrack has some folding treadmills, and the Peloton Tread does not fold.
• NordicTrack treadmills have a more cushioned deck, and the Peloton Tread has a deck that has a similar feeling to road running.

Technology and Features

Curious about what features and extras you might find on a Peloton Tread versus one of NordicTrack’s treadmills? Check out some of the things you can expect to see in the chart below. 

**Please note that all NordicTrack treadmills do not have the same extras; these are just some of the features you may find.**

Display

Winner: It depends

Not everyone wants a massive screen size, which makes this one of the most subjective categories. NordicTrack’s machines have screens as small as seven inches (EXP 7i) and as large as 32 inches (the Elite and Nordictrack X32i treadmill), so you’re bound to find something that works for you. The Peloton Tread has a 23.8-inch HD touchscreen, which has great graphics and is quite responsive when tapped.

Motor

Winner: NordicTrack

If you enjoy running, I recommend finding a treadmill that has at least a 3.0 CHP motor. Just as you’d want a car’s engine to be powerful enough for sustained driving, the same is true for a treadmill and its motor––you want to make sure it can handle frequent running.

The Peloton Tread has a 3.0 CHP motor, which would work just fine for most people. However, for especially serious runners, NordicTrack’s higher-end models have motors up to 4.25 CHP.

Speed, Incline, and Decline Options

Winner: NordicTrack

The Peloton Tread hits the nail on the head when it comes to speed range––expect to see the option to sprint up to 12.5 miles per hour. All of the NordicTrack treadmills max out at 12 miles per hour, so they are slightly slower than the Tread. 

However, the incline and decline options offered on multiple NordicTrack treadmills are much more impressive than that of the Tread. The Peloton Tread has incline options up to 12.5 percent, which is generally enough for the common exerciser. But, if you’re looking for a really impressive incline trainer, NordicTrack offers multiple models (like the Elite, X32i, and the X22i) that can go up to a 40 percent incline. 

I wish the Peloton Tread had decline options, but it doesn’t. Perhaps the brand will add this as a feature in an upcoming edition. If having a treadmill with decline is important to you, almost all of NordicTrack’s machines have it (sans the budget-friendly EXP 7i).  

RELATED: Best Incline Treadmill

Interactive Programming

Winner: Peloton

This category purely comes down to personal preference. I’ve tried both options extensively and was generally quite impressed with what each offered. iFIT has thousands of on-demand options including long-distance running, walking, and jogging classes. The programming service also has a variety of classes to take off the treadmill––think yoga, strength training, cycling, and more. 

I like that Peloton has both live and on-demand classes for you to enjoy. You’ll be able to race against people from around the world in a live class, and follow along with the leaderboard to see how you stack up. You can also enjoy audio-only running and walking classes if you prefer to just zone out and listen as you sweat. Similarly to iFIT, Peloton has plenty of other types of classes to take when you need a break from the Tread. Check out their newest rowing content or follow along with a strenuous dumbbell workout. 

RELATED: Dumbbell Leg Workout

Company Policies

Company policies are almost as important as the machines themselves. You don’t want to buy the most tricked-out option on the market and realize it has a warranty of five minutes or has an outrageous shipping fee attached. Check out the important company policies you should know about before selecting a Peloton Tread or one of NordicTrack’s machines. 

Shipping

Winner: Peloton

Peloton bakes in shipping and professional setup costs into the machine’s price tag, which is pretty smart, if you ask me. Once you’ve purchased a Tread, you just have to sit back and wait for two strangers to come and drag the machine into your home (in a few weeks, not right away). Viola, you’re ready to go without any additional fees!

NordicTrack does offer free delivery, but this means right outside of your house. Their machines are not lightweight by any means, so have fun dragging hundreds of pounds inside your door. Pretend you’re doing an epic sled workout to make yourself feel better. Or, better yet, forgo this back-breaking work and pay between $99 to $299 for professional delivery and assembly.

Return Policies

Winner: NordicTrack

NordicTrack and Peloton offer pretty standard returns: If you’re not satisfied with your purchase, you can send your treadmill back within 30 days of delivery for a refund. You may be charged a restocking fee for both brands if your machine doesn’t arrive back in its original condition.

The small difference between the two lies in the return shipping charge. NordicTrack charges $250 in fees, and Peloton makes you cough up $300 to send the Tread back.

Financing Options

Winner: NordicTrack

The financing options for both Peloton and NordicTrack are some of the best I’ve seen in the fitness industry. NordicTrack just barely edges out Peloton in this category, simply for the fact that you can spread your payments out a few additional months without having to pay an annual percentage rate.

You can finance the Peloton Tread through Affirm with zero money down (provided you qualify through a credit check). There are two options offered through Affirm: Either 0% APR financing for 12 months, or 14.995% APR financing for anywhere between 24 to 43 months.  

NordicTrack provides financing through TD Bank, which you also have to qualify for through a credit check. You’re not required to put down a down payment, and you can take advantage of 0% APR financing for 12 to 48 months.

Warranty

Winner: NordicTrack

The industry standard for a frame warranty on a treadmill is at least 15 years. Oddly, neither the Peloton Tread nor any of NordicTrack’s treadmills hit the mark. You’ll get a five-year frame warranty on the Peloton Tread and 10 years for any of NordicTrack’s offerings. Although NordicTrack has the longer warranty, this one is sort of a hollow victory (in my opinion).

Final Thoughts on Peloton Tread vs NordicTrack: What is the Best?

Although NordicTrack wins out in most of the categories covered above, they aren’t necessarily the best choice for everyone. Depending on the features and factors that you consider to be the most important, you may prefer one over the other. 

Since I personally enjoy Peloton’s programming quite a bit more than iFIT from NordicTrack, I’d probably choose a Peloton Tread. However, if things like incline training or a longer warranty are the most appealing factors to you, NordicTrack is your best bet. 

Peloton Tread vs NordicTrack FAQs

Caroline Lubinsky, CF-L1

Caroline is a former NCAA D1 Women’s College Soccer player who also played in the WPSL, the second highest level of professional women’s soccer in the United States. Although soccer was her first love, Caroline eats, sleeps, and breathes all things fitness. She credits her high school’s football coach, Jason Estep, with teaching her how to properly use a barbell at 15 years old and inspiring an enduring love for strength training. Caroline is also a CrossFit Level 1 Trainer. Content wise, Caroline has a background in Public Relations and previously worked in the Communication department at Appalachian State University. When Caroline isn’t writing or working out, she works with dachshund rescue groups and listens to way too many true crime podcasts.

Further reading

Athlete-Tested and Expert-Reviewed: The Best Olympic Barbells for 2024

by Anthony O'Reilly CPT, CNC

A barbell is the most versatile tool in any commercial or home gym. Check out our top picks to find the right one for you. Read more

Transparent Labs Collagen Hydrolysate Review (2024): Our Favorite Collagen Supplement

by Lindsay Boyers, CN

In this Transparent Labs Collagen Hydrolysate review, we’ll highlight our experience testing this supplement according to our rigorous testing methodology. Read more

Loosen Up with the 8 Best Hip Flexor Stretches 

by Christopher Covello

Do you have tight hip flexors? These hip flexor stretches get you feelin’ right when your flexors are tight! Check them out right here! Read more

FlexIt Fitness Review (2024): Flexible Virtual Training Focused Toward Your Goals

by Caine Wilkes, OLY, CNC, USAW-L1

This app connects you with a virtual trainer to coach you through your training, nutrition, and more. Find out more in our FlexIt Fitness review. Read more