Although I’m partial to a nice dumbbell (brb, dreaming of those beautiful UConn dumbbells Coop has), I do love using a barbell. Nothing makes me feel more large and in charge than loudly loading my bar and taking up a rack at the gym as I should. 

In this Barbell Logic Online Coaching review, I’ll detail what I did in my first month of training with my very own barbell coach. I definitely got stronger, but is it worth the steep price tag? Keep reading to find out.

Thousands of Hours With a Barbell

Between our expert product testers at Garage Gym Reviews, we’ve collectively spent thousands of hours with barbells. Our team is composed of certified personal trainers, former college athletes, CrossFit-L1 trainers, and health coaches. Some of us prefer powerlifting, while others love Olympic weightlifting. Regardless of what we each like to do with a barbell, our goals generally are the same––to get stronger. 

Barbell Logic Coaching

Barbell Logic Online Coaching Premium

Check Price

Product Highlights

STANDARD

Online Coaching from a SSC

$319/mo

*Three-month minimum commitment. (Paid out one month at a time)Get Started

Starting Strength Online Coaching provides high-touch, personalized online coaching from Starting Strength Coaches and unsurpassed customer service.

Pros & Cons

Bottom Line

A Quick Look at Barbell Logic Coaching

Matt Reynolds, who founded Barbell Logic in 2016, has over 25 years of experience coaching. “Matt is one of the few people I’ve met who is more eccentric than myself,” GGR founder Coop Mitchell says with a smile. “He has an all-in mindset and absolutely takes that into how he runs Barbell Logic and treats their clients.”

My Tips:

• Make sure you have a working phone camera to take videos with, otherwise you won’t get the most out of this program. 
• Take the time to communicate with your coach––they can switch up workouts if things aren’t meshing for you. 
• Free supplemental content is available on the Barbell Logic website.

Is Barbell Logic Coaching Worth It?

Barbell Logic Online Coaching is something a lot of gym junkies will eat up with a big spoon. However, it won’t be everyone’s favorite flavor. Check out who I think would love this coaching, and who should try something else:

Barbell Logic Online Coaching Specs

Using Barbell Logic Online Coaching: Coop’s Experience

Coop previously followed the Barbell Logic program for 90 days. Here is his experience (as told by Coop himself): 

Getting Started

The entire program started with a questionnaire. In it, I was asked my training history, medical history, and various questions on the equipment I had access to and the times I could train. While taking the questionnaire, I was happy they were asking so many questions because I assumed it led to very personalized programming. 

For instance, in my questionnaire, when asked what my goals were, in the short-term I wanted to increase hypertrophy and in the long-term I wanted to achieve a 500-pound squat and a 205-pound overhead press. The training we did was great for strength, but not for hypertrophy. I get the feeling that for the most part, no matter your goals, they’re going to use a similar training template to get you there.

Training With Barbell Logic

I don’t want to give away all that we did in the 90 days, but I will say that my training centered around five movements: squat, deadlift, press, bench press, and weighted chin-ups. We also did some light power cleans, but it was a very small part of the program (As an aside, I really need to improve my pull in the clean.)

I squatted two to three times a week, deadlifted twice a week, and alternated bench press and the overhead press with some chin-ups. That’s about it. Coming from high-volume, varied programming that I’ve been following for quite some time, it was a bit of a shock. 

The main difficulty for me throughout the program was the lack of variety. I get that variety isn’t always optimal (although I’m sure that could be argued), but it does add some spice. That said, I blew all of my previous personal records out of the water at the end of the 90 days, so I’d say the satisfaction of that was more than “loving” my training everyday. Check out my numbers: 

Squat

Previous All-Time Best: 425 pounds

New All-Time Best: 465 pounds

Bench

Previous All-Time Best: 300 pounds

New All-Time Best: 325 pounds

Deadlift

Previous All-Time Best: 515 pounds

New All-Time Best: 518 pounds

Overhead Press

Previous All-Time Best: 190 pounds

New All-Time Best: 215 pounds

Using Barbell Logic: Caroline’s Experience

Caroline here! After hearing about Coop’s previous experience, I was excited to give Barbell Logic Online Coaching a try. As a former NCAA D1 Women’s College Soccer player, I know my way around a barbell (5 a.m. lifts anyone?). However, cardio is still my forté, so I was a little nervous about lifting heavy again, especially with lingering injuries from my high school, collegiate, and semi-pro soccer career.

The Barbell Logic coaching process started with a very in-depth form, which asked about your previous experience with working out, current habits, and more. This is sent to your email after you sign up for one of three coaching options––Exclusive ($285 per month), Professional ($225 per month), or Club ($155 per month). You’ll pay $0 at sign up—no discount code necessary—then pay monthly after that.

Let me take a moment and acknowledge the price of these options; I know this is unattainable for some people and I do wish it was less expensive. Ultimately though, you’re getting professional guidance from someone with years of experience, and that isn’t going to be cheap.

All three coaching options include weekly programming and prompt feedback from your coach about form. The online descriptions on what varies between Exclusive, Professional, and Club level coaching is a bit confusing––Barbell Logic could improve their descriptions to let you know what extras you’re getting at each level.

Nevertheless, I selected the Exclusive level coaching to see what Barbell Logic was really all about. You can also add Nutrition coaching for an additional $150 per month, which I also decided to do (more on that later).

Let’s Get JACKED With Barbell Logic

After a mere 24 hours post questionnaire, I was matched with a Barbell Logic strength coach, Niki Sims. Niki is a jack-of-all-trades––she formerly owned a CrossFit box, has over a decade of experience as a lifting coach, competes in jujitsu, and co-hosts the Barbell Logic podcast with founder Matt Reynolds. Phew, she is one busy woman!

Niki (and I assume any other coach you’re working with) sent me her calendar with an invite to have a one-on-one chat. I connected with her right away, and chatted her ear off for a good 30 minutes (sorry Niki!). We talked about any roadblocks I may have to training and my goal, which was to get stronger. 

We settled on three days of lifting per week (I also play soccer and do HIIT two other days). The program starts off with getting your maxes on things like deadlift, back squat, and overhead press. Unlike Future, you don’t access your workouts through an app, but rather a webpage. This has worked out fine, but I think it would be more user-friendly for Barbell Logic to transfer to an app. 

On the days you have a workout scheduled, your coach will send a reminder email with your workout enclosed. If you miss a workout, you will also receive an email to remind you of your wrongdoing (just kidding). Through each email, you’ll be able to click on your workout to input specific weight and add videos for review. 

Maybe I’m just weird, but I felt like an Instagram influencer taking videos of myself in the gym. Mind you, I don’t have enough space for my own home gym, so I workout at the YMCA near my condo. There is truly nothing more humbling than blatantly filming yourself deadlifting in a full gym at 6 p.m. I didn’t love that part of the training, but I understand that it is necessary in order for my coach to get an accurate picture (er, video) of my form, especially since you’re not working with them in person. 

The video reviews on my form from Niki are easily the highlight of the program. The actual sets and reps weren’t anything mind-blowing (as Coop said above), but they are what actually work if your goal is to get stronger. After each workout (where I would attach a video for each exercise), Niki would offer pointers and cues for me. 

Even though I know how to perform the common lifts, having these little extra cues can be the difference between you pulling more weight versus getting injured. For a beginner, who could benefit from novice linear progression programming, this could be a crucial step in your lifting journey if you’ve never had anyone break down the exercises before. For an intermediate or advanced lifter, these can assist you in refining your technique and progressing your weight. 

If you can afford Barbell Logic coaching, it will change the way you lift weights for the better. I truly think almost anyone at any level can benefit from this type of in-depth instruction. 

Equipment Requirements

As the name suggests, you need to have access to a barbell in order to do Barbell Logic Coaching. They also ask that you have various weight plates, and a rack. I personally used my favorite, the Rogue Ohio bar, for all of my lifts (shoutout to the YMCA of Greater Charlotte for the great barbell selection). 

However, Niki was wonderful about making adjustments on the fly. I went on a last-minute trip to Richmond, Virginia, and didn’t have access to a barbell and plates. She kindly programmed bodyweight workouts in place of my usual lifts, which was a big help for me. 

Nutrition Coaching

Compared to the regular Barbell Logic coaching, the Nutrition portion is limited. I took a questionnaire similar to the one used for the barbell portion of the coaching––I was asked about previous eating habits, what I wanted to work on eating-wise, and any roadblocks I may face. Unfortunately, after truthfully answering the questions, I received an email that the program could not do Nutrition coaching with me due to a previous eating disorder. 

While disappointed, I’m glad they know their limits on what they can and cannot handle. In the fine print under the Nutrition Coaching information on the website, the team details a list of conditions they are unable to work with including things like GERD and IBS. Tummy ache survivors, stay away. 

It was also interesting for me to note that they do not use registered dietitians or nutritionists for this program (as stated in the fine print). With so much expertise and experience on the barbell side, I feel like they should also carry this over into nutrition if they are going to offer it. 

Barbell Logic Online Coaching vs. Future

Future

Future

GGR Score: 4.7

Check Price First month is $50 when you use our link

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Incredible user interface; very well designed and intuitive
• Choose your own coach based on your personal preferences and goals
• Lots of variety in your workouts

Cons

• $199 per month membership cost
• No real-time coaching from your trainer

Bottom Line

Future is similar to Barbell Logic in that they both involve real coaches delivering workouts virtually to their clients. However, this is pretty much where the similarities stop (although both do share a hefty price tag). 

Future is personal training delivered through an interactive app (only available for iPhones unfortunately), and focuses on your specific goals. This could be anything from trying to run a mile in seven minutes flat, to performing a handstand scorpion. Whatever you’re trying to achieve, your hand-picked personal trainer will create workouts to help you work towards these goals. They’ll check in with you via short messages throughout the week to see if you need any modifications (and motivation).

On the other hand, Barbell Logic is quite barbell-focused (shocker). Your coach has the goal of making you stronger, period. This will involve various progressions on common lifts, like squats, deadlifts, and overhead presses. Your coach will request videos of your sets and offer form feedback, which I find very valuable. 

Both of these programs are extremely well-done, no doubt about it. Figuring out the right option for you will really come down to your own individual goals. For those who have a specific objective they want to achieve (i.e something like running a marathon or doing 15 pull-ups), Future will probably work better for you. If you’re looking to gain strength overall and lift with better form, go for Barbell Logic.

Final Verdict of Our Barbell Logic Review

In conclusion, both Coop and I would recommend Barbell Logic Online Coaching. It’s costly, but you get what you pay for. If you just want a simple workout without accountability, pay for a $20 service. If you want to follow a program that will get you stronger (with correct form) and improve your quality of life, sign up for Barbell Logic. Here are my takeaways:

• The pointers and adjustments suggested by the coaches will help you learn (or refine) common lifts, which can be crucial for preventing unnecessary injury due to improper technique. 
• Cost may be prohibitive for some people.
• Must have a barbell, plates, and a rack.

Full Rating

Barbell Logic Online Coaching

Barbell Logic, formerly Starting Strength Online Coaching is an online coaching program that utilizes Mark Rippetoe's Starting Strength Book as a basis for its programming. After testing the programming over 90 days, I not only hit lifetime bests in every lift, I greatly enjoyed the entire experience. We highly recommend SSOC to any trainee, especially garage gym owners, looking to increase strength.

Product Brand: Barbell Logic

Product Currency: USD

Product Price: 219

Product In-Stock: InStock

Editor's Rating:
4.5

Barbell Logic Online Coaching FAQs

Caroline Lubinsky, CF-L1

Caroline is a former NCAA D1 Women’s College Soccer player who also played in the WPSL, the second highest level of professional women’s soccer in the United States. Although soccer was her first love, Caroline eats, sleeps, and breathes all things fitness. She credits her high school’s football coach, Jason Estep, with teaching her how to properly use a barbell at 15 years old and inspiring an enduring love for strength training. Caroline is also a CrossFit Level 1 Trainer. Content wise, Caroline has a background in Public Relations and previously worked in the Communication department at Appalachian State University. When Caroline isn’t writing or working out, she works with dachshund rescue groups and listens to way too many true crime podcasts.

Further reading

Kettle Gryp Review (2024): Have Gryp, Will Travel

by Caine Wilkes, OLY, CNC, USAW-L1

Is the Kettle Gryp the best travel option for workouts on the go? Read more on this budget-friendly item in our Kettle Gryp review. Read more

What Is Red Light Therapy? And How It Works

by Caine Wilkes, OLY, CNC, USAW-L1

This emerging field in the world of biohacking and recovery isn’t well understood yet. What is red light therapy? We take a deep dive in this article. Read more

Spin Bike vs Exercise Bike: Saddle-Up For Cycling Success

by Stacey L. Nash, CPT

Pondering spin bike vs exercise bike for your next cardio session? The machines may seem similar, but there are a few differences to consider. Learn more! Read more

Cronometer Review (2024): When You Want to Track More Than Just Calories

by Chelsea Rae Bourgeois, MS, RDN, LD

Dietary intake plays a key role in wellness, and this Cronometer review shows how nutrition tracking can be a game-changer in maximizing health. Read more